The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

Chapter 23

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"At seven I call anyway."

"At seven you call anyway. That's my brave girl."

He stood up, and she stood with him, clutching his phone to her chest with both hands the way she carried breakable things from the kitchen. At the glass door he stopped her with a hand on her shoulder, because the house on the other side of the glass was no longer the house she had eaten breakfast in, and they both knew it.

"Straight to your room," he said. "Don't call out. Don't look for anybody. If you see Mommy Simone, don't argue and don't explain — go past her fast, into your room, and lock the door. Can you do that for me?"

Lily looked through the glass at the dim, familiar hall, and then up at him, and what she said then was the sentence he carried down into the water with him later, and would still be hearing on ordinary mornings for years.

"She's my mommy in there," Lily said, nodding toward the house, "but she's not my *mommy*. I know the difference now. You know it too. That's why you're not scared the same."

Then she slipped through the door he opened for her, barefoot and silent, a small yellow figure crossing the shadowed hall with a telephone held to her heart like a lamp — and Caleb closed the glass softly behind her, and turned on the deck, dripping in the sun, with Elena's phone in one hand and Elena's key a small hard weight against his thigh, and faced the pool, and the house, and the woman who would have to come out of it, and waited for her to come.

Chapter 7: The Key

The sun had not moved, or it seemed that way to Caleb. It still stood hard and white above the roof, still made the turquoise water glitter so brightly that looking at it hurt. Everything ordinary was still there — towels over the lounger, Lily's plastic cup beside a smear of sunscreen, the smell of chlorine and hot stone — and none of it was ordinary anymore. He stood dripping where he had stood when the call ended, and in one hand, raised between thumb and forefinger so the light caught it, he held the small brass key.

It was dull at the edges, bright along one side where it had rubbed against coins and leather, with a round bow and a short bit cut for one lock only. It weighed almost nothing. That was the obscenity of it: a thing so light could close a door under the water and keep it closed for two years.

Simone stood a few feet away, still wet from the pool. Her green silk dress clung to her, darkened almost to black in patches, and drops ran from its hem onto the tiles. Her hair was plastered against her neck. She had stopped laughing. In the pool her face had been wild with that wrong, ringing laugh, her hands fisted in his shirt. Now she was very still, and her eyes were not on his face. They were on the key. She knew at once where he had found it, and what else must have been there with it. The ring. The phone. Her stillness was not innocence. It was calculation, happening fast behind a face trying to arrange itself into something he would believe.

"You went through my bag," she said.

"I did."

"You had no right."

It was such a small, domestic complaint, so perfectly sized for a marriage, that for a second he almost answered it in kind — fourteen months of shared drawers and bills, of Simone moving through this house as if every cupboard had always been hers. Then he looked again at the key.

"I found Elena's wedding ring in your wallet," he said. "In the coin pocket. Zipped in. I found her phone in your bag. Charged, Simone. After two years. Charged and kept. And I found this."

It hung in the sunlight between them, turning slightly on the tremor in his fingers.

"So I am going to ask you questions," he said. "In order. And you are going to answer them where Lily can hear you lie, if lying is what you choose to do."

At her name, Lily made a small sound.

She stood between them — not exactly between them, because no adult had placed her there, but in the narrow space where a child goes when both people she loves are in the same dangerous weather. Her yellow sundress was damp at the hem. Her hair, in its two buns, had begun to dry and curl at the wisps. Her hands were clasped at her chest, fingers laced and pressed so tightly that the tips had gone white. She was crying without any noise except the hitch in her breathing, and she did not wipe the tears away.

Caleb wanted to pick her up and carry her into the cool of the house, where she could not see this. But he had carried her away from the truth before, without knowing — past explained-away sounds, while Simone smiled and poured juice — and if he did it now, he would teach her again that what she heard did not matter when an adult's voice was louder. So he stayed, and let her stay where she could hear.

"Lily," he said gently, not looking away from Simone, because he did not dare. "Stay just there for Daddy, all right? Don't come closer."

"I don't want to," Lily whispered, which could have meant anything, and Caleb answered as if she had meant the first thing.

News in the same category

The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

45 Part