And Caleb — who had believed the note, and married the handwriting, and poured the cereal and said *a dream* over the sound of knocking through the pipes of his own house — Caleb understood that there would be exactly one chance to be, from this minute, the man his daughter had pointed at the water believing him to be. It would not look like courage. It would look like housekeeping. He reached up, gently, and closed his hands over Simone's where they gripped his shirt, and he held them — not prising them off, simply holding them, the way you hold something that is going to be taken away — and he said, "Lily. Go inside for me, sweetheart. Into the kitchen. Stay there until I come and get you. Can you do that?"
Lily nodded. She stood, slowly, her wet feet leaving two small, perfect prints on the tile that dried even as he watched, and she went — not running, which he thought he would be proud of for the rest of his life — up the path and through the glass door into the house.
Simone watched her go too. When the door slid shut, something in the pool changed; the performance lost its audience of one, and there was only the two of them left in the bright water, husband and wife, holding each other like dancers in a flooded ballroom.
"What did you tell her?" Simone asked suddenly, quieter, and the question was so nakedly the wrong one — not *what have you done*, not *which of us has she believed*, but the bookkeeper's question, the archivist's, *what is now on the record* — that he nearly laughed himself, in horror. "When she ran to you. Before. What exactly did she say?"
"She said her mother is under the water," Caleb said. "She said it the way you'd say the postman has come. And do you know the worst of it, Simone? She wasn't surprised. A six-year-old told me there is a woman locked under her swimming pool, and she wasn't surprised, because for her it isn't news. It's weather. It's the thing that knocks. She's grown up alongside it, the way you and Elena grew up alongside that vault — it was just part of the house to you. Grandfather's house that keeps things." His hands tightened, gently, over hers. "The house will keep what you put in it. Elena told me he used to say that. She told me on our honeymoon, as a joke. As a *joke*, Simone."
"Don't," Simone said. For the first time, she tried to pull her hands free — not violently, worse than violently: privately, as if some part of the afternoon had at last become too intimate even for her. "Don't you use him."
"Let go of my hands," Simone said, in her own voice at last — the one under all the others, dry and tired and forty-two years old. "You can't open it anyway. You haven't got—" She stopped herself. Her eyes flickered, once, involuntarily, across the deck.
To the patio table. To the pitcher of lemonade, and the glasses, and the folded towel.
To her handbag, sitting in the shade of the umbrella where she had left it when she came out to find them — the brown monogrammed bag she carried everywhere, that went from room to room of the house with her like a second, smaller house, that no one ever opened because it was hers.
Caleb followed the look, and felt her hands go slack and desperate in his at the same moment, and he was already moving — up out of the water in a surge, hauling himself onto the deck with the strength of pure purpose, streaming, shoeless now — one shoe had come off somewhere below, he never found it — crossing the hot tiles toward the table while behind him the water erupted with Simone, screaming his name, in a voice that had finished, at last, with gentleness altogether.
Chapter 5: The Handbag
The bag was where she had left it.
Caleb saw it the moment he came up the pool steps, water pouring off him, his wet shoes squelching on the hot tiles. It sat on the glass-topped table between the two loungers at the deep end, in the full sun, exactly where Simone had set it down when she came out of the house that afternoon — before Lily's voice had changed everything. Before the door under the water.
A brown designer handbag, the leather darkened at the handles from use. On the front, worked into the flap in thread only slightly lighter than the bag itself, was a monogram: two letters intertwined.
He had bought it for her — last Christmas. That was the worst of it, standing there dripping with his heart slamming.
Simone had dragged herself out at the shallow steps behind him. He heard her say his name once, low and furious, and then the long glass door of the house slid and shut with a force that made the panes tremble. She had gone inside — to fetch a towel, to fetch her temper back, to telephone someone, perhaps. For the first time in fourteen months of marriage, he did not go after her.
"Lily," he said, without turning. "Stay on the lounger, sweetheart. Right there. Don't come near the water."
"Okay, Daddy."
Her voice was small and hoarse from crying. She sat where he had left her, her yellow dress dark at the hem where the pool water had soaked it, her bare feet very still, watching him as if he had become a different kind of father in the last ten minutes — one who went down into the pool instead of calling her away from it.
He set his wet hand on the bag.