The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He almost argued with the story then, because her performance — for that was what it was, a performance that had run for two years without an intermission — was reaching for its strongest ground: the note, the leaving, the wound he had organised his grief around. She had fed it smaller explanations at exactly the moments it threatened to ask a larger question. His fault, the ordinary one: he had believed the story he was given because believing it hurt less than the alternative. So he did not argue with the story. He brought out the thing that was not a story.

"Her phone rang," he said. "Just now. In my hand."

Simone stopped breathing. He saw it happen. Her chest, rising on some prepared sentence, simply ceased, and her wet dress dripped onto the tiles, tick, tick, into the quiet.

"An unknown number," Caleb said. "I answered it, and I didn't say a word, because by then I'd seen the ring, and I'd seen this key, and some part of me — the part that finally did its job today — knew not to speak first. And a man spoke to me, Simone. A man who thought he was speaking to you. Shall I tell Lily what he said, or will you?"

"Don't."

It came out bare, unadorned — not a denial and not a plea. A reflex. The first wholly honest sound she had made. Don't. Not I don't know, not you're lying. Don't.

"He said she was knocking through the wall again," Caleb said evenly, because Lily was there, and because horror, spoken evenly, could not be mistaken for madness. "He said she was knocking while the kid was sitting right there. Those were his words. The kid. Sitting right there, at the pool, with her feet in the water, hearing her mother knock on a door under the ground. He said: you said tonight. He said: I'll bring the van at nine."

Lily had gone absolutely still, her hands clasped at her chest, her wet cheeks shining, looking from one face to the other with the terrible attentiveness of a child who knows the words spoken over her head are, at last, about the thing she has been saying all along.

"The van at nine, Simone," Caleb said. "For what?"

Her face changed then. The concern went, and the warmth went, and the wounded wife went with them, stripped in sequence like costumes pulled off a rail — and what was underneath was not monstrous. That was the worst of it. What was underneath was a woman of forty-two who had wanted a thing for most of her life and had taken it with both hands, and who was now watching it pried from her grip, and hated him for it with a plain, comprehensible hatred.

"You were never supposed to look down there," she said.

It was the same slip she had made in the water, returned now without the laughter, delivered quietly and with contempt, as if he had broken a household rule of no importance. As if the door, and what lay behind it, were a cupboard she had asked him politely to leave shut.

"Say her name," Caleb said.

"What?"

"Elena. Say her name, and tell me where she is."

"She's gone."

"She's knocking."

"She is gone!" Simone cried, and the cry tore the afternoon properly open. "She has been gone for two years, because that is what I — " She stopped, closing her mouth with an audible click of teeth. But the sentence had shown its shape: Because that is what I — arranged. Decided. Did. The unfinished verb hung in the sun between them, and Simone knew he had seen it, and Caleb knew she knew.

"Because that is what you what?" he asked, very quietly.

She shook her head, her wet hair swinging, droplets spattering the tiles near Lily's bare feet. "No. I won't. You don't get to do this. Do you know what it was like, growing up in this house as the other one? Everything was Elena. The pretty one. The kind one. This house promised in everything but writing. And then you. She got you without even trying. She had the life. This life. It just came to her, the way weather comes."

"And Lily?" Caleb said. He was trembling all over now, and made no attempt to hide it. "Did Lily just come to you too? A part of the house? Like a chair?"

"Don't you dare." Her voice dropped and hardened, and found a steadiness more frightening than her shouting. "I raised her. I brushed that hair. I sat up with her fevers. Mine. That is not a word you get to take back because of a key."

"She isn't yours," Caleb said. "Her mother is under our pool."

It was Simone who moved first — not away, not toward the house or the gate, but directly at him, and at the small brass thing shining in his raised hand, with a speed that told him she must have been measuring the distance for minutes. She lunged. One moment she stood with her hands open in false surrender, and the next she was across the space between them, green silk snapping wetly, her face set not on him but on his fingers. Lily screamed, a single high note, and stumbled backward with her hands still clasped, as if she had forgotten in terror that hands could be used for anything else.

News in the same category

The Little Girl in the Yellow Dress Who Pointed at the Pool and Said Her Mother Was Under the Water

45 Part