I looked around the kitchen with Emily still in my arms, and I saw the knife block on the counter, and I could not reach it without putting Emily down, and I did not want to put Emily down, not for one second, not after what she had been through, so I stood up with her in my arms, her legs wrapped around my waist, the rabbit still clutched against her chest, and I carried her across the kitchen, and I took the biggest knife out of the block, and I carried it to the top of the basement stairs, and I held it out, handle first, and Paul came up two steps and took it from me, and our eyes met for a second, and I saw in his face exactly what I was feeling in my own chest, which was that this was real, this was really happening, in our neighbors' house, on our street, on a night when we had only gone out to hang Christmas lights.
"Stay up here," he said. "Keep her up here. Don't bring her down. Whatever you do, don't bring her down here."
"I won't," I said. "I promise. I won't."
He went back down the stairs, and I stood at the top with Emily in my arms, and I listened to the sounds coming up from the basement, Paul's voice, low and gentle now, talking the way you talk to a frightened animal, and the sound of the knife sawing, and then a soft cry, a woman's voice, thin and hoarse, like someone who has not spoken in a long time, and Emily stiffened in my arms when she heard it, and she lifted her head off my shoulder, and she said, "Mommy?"
"Yes, sweetheart," I whispered. "Yes. That's your mommy. That's your mommy down there, and Paul is helping her, and she's going to be all right."
I could hear Paul talking to her, telling her his name, telling her that she was safe, telling her that her daughter was upstairs with me and that her daughter was safe, and I could hear Rachel's voice answering him, weak and broken, words I could not make out, and then I heard Paul say, "All right, all right, easy now, I've got you, lean on me, that's it, one step at a time," and I heard the slow, careful sound of two people coming up a flight of stairs together, one of them helping the other, one step, and then another, and then another, and then they were at the top of the stairs, and I saw her.
Rachel Halvorsen was standing in the doorway of the basement with Paul's arm around her shoulders, holding her up, and she looked like a woman who had been through a war. Her face was bruised, dark purple and yellow along one cheekbone and down the side of her jaw, and there was dried blood near her hairline, a dark crust where it had run down from a cut on her forehead and dried there, and there were tape marks on her mouth, pale rectangles on her skin where tape had been pulled off, the skin underneath raw and pink. Her hands were bound in front of her with rope, the rope wound tight around her wrists, and her wrists were red and swollen where the rope had bitten into them, and her clothes were torn at the shoulder, and her hair was matted, and she was shivering, shivering so hard that her teeth were chattering, and she was barefoot, her feet dirty and cold on the kitchen tile. But she was breathing. She was standing. She was alive. She had been missing for two days, and she was alive, and she was standing in her mother-in-law's kitchen, leaning on my husband, and looking at me with eyes that were wide and unfocused, like she was not sure if she was awake or dreaming.