Paul brought the boxes up from the garage on the first Saturday in December, and the air was cold enough that I could see my breath, and the sky was that flat winter gray that makes the whole world look like it is waiting for something. He set the boxes on the driveway and opened the first one, and the smell of dust and old plastic came up out of it, and the strings of lights were tangled the way they always are, no matter how carefully you wind them, and he laughed at that, a real laugh, and I laughed too, and it felt strange and good to be laughing out there in the yard in December, because laughter had not come easily to us in that yard for a long time. The ladder leaned against the gutter, and Paul climbed it with the clips in his pocket, and I stood below holding the string and feeding it up to him, and the work was slow and ordinary, and that was the point. Ordinary was the whole point. My hands were cold and the clips were small and I kept dropping them, and Paul kept catching them or fishing them out of the grass, and we worked our way along the front of the house, and the lights went up one strand at a time, and with every strand the house looked a little less like a house that had something terrible happen in front of it and a little more like a house where people lived and decorated for Christmas.
I kept thinking about last December while we worked, and I did not try to stop myself, because I have learned that trying not to think about something is the fastest way to think about nothing else. Last December we had been hanging lights too, Paul and I, out in this same yard, on a ladder just like this one, and we had been laughing about something small, something I cannot even remember now, and then we had heard it, the sound that changed everything, and we had run across the street with the lights still in our hands, and the rest of that night had unfolded the way it did, and the year after it had unfolded the way it did, with the arrests and the questions and the quiet and the empty house across the street. And now here we were, a year later, hanging lights in the same yard, and the difference was that this time we were choosing to be out here, and we were choosing it on purpose, and there is a kind of power in that, in choosing, that I had not understood until I felt it in my own cold hands, holding a string of lights and feeding it up to my husband, who is a high school history teacher and who has spent his whole working life telling teenagers that the past matters and the future is not written yet, and who was up on a ladder in December proving it.
The Halvorsen house sat across the street while we worked, and I could feel it there even when I was not looking at it, the way you can feel a cold room when you walk past an open door. It was still empty and dark, the windows blank, the curtains drawn, the driveway empty, the porch light off, and it had been that way for a year, ever since Tom Halvorsen and Mark Halvorsen were arrested, and nobody had moved in, and nobody had come to clear it out properly, and the neighborhood had gotten used to it the way you get used to a missing tooth, always aware of the gap even when you are not touching it. I looked at it once, just once, while Paul was untangling a knot, and I thought about how a house can hold a darkness the way a room holds a smell, and how for a year that darkness had felt like it owned the whole street, like it had put its name on the neighborhood and we were all just living under it. And then I looked away, back at our own house, at the lights going up, and I thought, not anymore. Not this December. Not while I am standing here with cold hands and a string of lights and a husband on a ladder. The darkness does not get to own the whole neighborhood. It gets the house across the street, for now, because that is where it happened and that is where it lives, but it does not get the rest of us, and it does not get this yard, and it does not get Christmas.