We decorated the tree together, the five of us, and it was slow and happy work, the kind of work that does not feel like work at all. Paul put the star on top, or tried to, and it kept slipping, and Rachel steadied the ladder, and Linda handed up the ornaments one at a time, and I hung the glass balls low where Emily could reach them, and Emily hung them wherever she wanted, which was mostly in one clump on one branch, and nobody corrected her, because it was her clump and her branch and her tree, in a way, and it looked wonderful. And then Linda reached into her bag and took out something wrapped in tissue paper, and she unwrapped it carefully, and it was a paper angel ornament, a little angel made of folded paper, white and gold, with wings that spread when you held it up, and she held it out to Emily, and she said Emily should hang it herself, and Emily took it with both hands, as gently as if it were made of glass, and she looked at it for a long moment, turning it this way and that, watching the wings catch the light, and then she reached up, on her tiptoes, stretching as tall as she could, and she hung it on a branch near the top of the tree, by herself, and she stepped back and looked at it, and she smiled, and the gap where her tooth used to be showed, and I thought my heart would break and mend itself at the same time, because here was this child, a year after the worst thing, hanging a paper angel on a Christmas tree in our living room, with her own hands, and the angel stayed, and she stayed, and we were all still here.
Linda told me later, while Rachel and Paul were in the kitchen with the coffee and Emily was arranging and rearranging the ornaments on the lower branches, that Emily had made the angel at school, that she had worked on it for days, that she had been very particular about the wings, and that she had said she wanted to hang it on our tree, not theirs, because our tree was the one she could see from the street, and I nodded, and I did not say anything for a moment, because there was too much in my throat to say anything, and Linda put her hand on my arm, and we stood there together looking at the tree, and at the angel, and at Emily, and I understood that this was what healing looked like, not a big announcement, not a ceremony, just a child hanging a paper angel on a tree and a mother and a grandmother standing nearby and letting her.
When the tree was done, or as done as it was going to be, we sat down with the cookies and the coffee and the hot chocolate for Emily, and the living room was warm and the lights from the tree threw soft colors on the walls, and outside the window the lights on the front of the house glowed, and for a little while it was just an afternoon, just a December afternoon with neighbors and cookies and a decorated tree, and I let myself enjoy it, I really did, because I had spent a year not enjoying things, or enjoying them only halfway, with one eye always on the dark house across the street, and I was tired of that, and I wanted this, and I deserved this, and so did they.
But of course it was not only an afternoon, and of course the other things were still there, underneath, the way they always are, and as the light outside began to fade and the room got a little quieter, Emily came and sat beside me on the couch, close, the way children do when they want to be near someone and do not quite know how to ask, and she was quiet for a while, looking at the tree, looking at the angel, and then she reached out and took my hand, her small hand in mine, warm from the hot chocolate, a little sticky from the cookies, and she looked up at me, and she asked me, in a voice that was very small and very serious, "Are we safe now?" And the room went quiet, or maybe it only felt quiet to me, because Paul stopped talking and Linda stopped talking and Rachel stopped talking, and everyone was listening, and I looked down at this child, taller than she had been a year ago, missing a front tooth, holding my hand, asking me the one question that mattered, and I knew I had to answer it right, not with a lie and not with a promise I could not keep, but with the truth, the truth as I understood it, a year later, sitting on my couch in December with Christmas lights in the window and a paper angel on the tree.