They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

Chapter 36

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

There were hearings I did not attend, and hearings I did. The ones I attended were mostly waiting. You sit on a bench outside a courtroom and you watch people come and go, lawyers with their briefcases, families with their coats still on, a bailiff who knows everyone's name, and you wait for your name to be called, and then you go in, and you sit, and you listen, and then you are told to come back. Paul came with me every time. He is a history teacher, and he has a way of sitting still that I have always admired, and in those hallways he sat still and he held my hand, and he did not say much, and that was enough. Once, in February, we saw Tom being brought in, in handcuffs, with an officer on either side of him, and he looked smaller than I remembered him. That surprised me. I had expected him to look large, the way he had looked that night on the ladder, when he was lifting his wife's legs into a bin. But in the courthouse hallway he looked small, and ordinary, and tired, and I felt something I did not expect to feel, which was not pity, exactly, but a kind of emptiness, as if the man I had been afraid of had never really been as big as my fear had made him. He did not look at us. Mark was not there that day. I do not know where he was. I did not ask.

The defense, when it came, was what you would expect. Tom's lawyer said that Linda was confused, that she had wandered before, that she had agreed to go with her husband, that the tape on her wrists was for her own safety, so she would not hurt herself, that the bin was a hiding place, not a prison, that the whole thing had been exaggerated by neighbors who did not understand the family. I listened to that, through the detective, through the prosecutor, through the news, and I thought about the note, and the broken phone, and the suitcase, and the map, and I thought about how a story can be told in two ways, and one of those ways is a lie, and the lie is always the one that asks you to ignore what you saw with your own eyes. I saw the bin. I saw the lid open. I saw Linda's face. I saw the tape on her wrists. I saw the garbage bags on top of her. No lawyer can make me unsee that. No argument can make that into a misunderstanding. And the evidence agreed with me. The tape was not the kind of tape you use to keep someone safe. The phone had not broken itself. The map had not drawn itself. The suitcase had not packed itself. The note had not written itself. And the neighbors had not imagined the bin. The evidence was overwhelming, and the word overwhelming, which I had always thought was a word people used when they wanted to sound important, turned out to be exactly the right word. It overwhelmed the lies. It buried them, the way the garbage bags had buried Linda, except this time the thing being buried was the story Tom had built, and the thing being uncovered was the truth.

I want to say something about the Halvorsen house in those months, because it stayed dark, and the darkness became a part of the street, the way a missing tooth becomes a part of a smile. People avoided looking at it. Children hurried past it on their way to school. The mail piled up, and then someone, I never learned who, started taking it in, so it would not pile up, so the house would not look abandoned, so the street would not have to admit that the house was empty. The bin was gone, seized as evidence, and the curb where it had sat looked bare, and I would look at that bare spot every time I came home, and I would think about the two days it had sat there after the arrests, green and dented and ordinary, and how nobody had touched it, how nobody had wanted to touch it, as if it were cursed, as if the horror of what had been inside it had soaked into the plastic. When the police finally came for it, they loaded it into a truck, and they were careful with it, and I was glad they were careful, because it deserved to be treated as evidence, not as garbage. It had held a woman. It had held a person. It was not garbage. It never had been.

News in the same category

They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

45 Part