I have to say that again, because I have to make myself understand it, and I still do not understand it. The garbage truck comes Monday morning. That was the plan. That was the timeline. He was not trying to kill her in the moment, or at least that is what he told himself, or that is what he told the police later. He was trying to hide her until Monday morning, when the truck would come and take the bin and take her with it, and the problem would be gone, and no one would ever know. He was going to let the garbage truck solve his problem for him. He was going to let a machine and a schedule and a Monday morning route do what he did not have the nerve to do himself, or what he did not want to see himself do, and he was going to stand in his driveway on Monday and wave at the driver the way he waved at everyone, and then go back inside his house and help his son disappear with a six-year-old girl.
I think about the cold. It was December, or close to it, and it was dark, and it was cold, and Linda was taped up and stuffed into a plastic bin, and she was alive, and she could hear the world going on around her, and she could not speak, and she could not move her hands, and she was waiting to be taken away by a truck. I think about what she must have thought in that bin. I think about whether she thought about Emily, and about Rachel, and about whether anyone would ever find her. I think about whether she thought about the note under the kitchen table, and whether she wondered if anyone would ever look there. I think about the sound of the lid closing, and the dark, and the cold seeping through the plastic, and I think about how long a night can feel when you are waiting to die and you cannot even scream.
And that is when I understood how close it came. I understood it all at once, the way you understand a thing when someone turns a light on in a room you have been sitting in for an hour without seeing it, and the understanding hit me so hard that I had to sit down, right there in my own living room, with Paul standing next to me, and I said it out loud, and hearing it out loud made it worse and also made it real.
If Paul and I had not gone out to hang Christmas lights that Sunday night, Linda might have been left in the cold overnight. That is the truth of it. If we had stayed inside. If we had decided to do the lights on Monday instead. If it had been raining. If Paul had been tired. If I had said, let us do it tomorrow, let us just stay in and watch television, let us not bother tonight. If any one of those small things had gone differently, Linda would have spent the night in that bin, in the cold, taped up and unable to call for help, and by morning the truck would have come, and by the time anyone thought to look for her, she would have been gone.
And Rachel would still have been tied to that post in the basement. Two days had already passed by the time anyone understood, and she would have been there longer, colder, weaker, with no water and no food and no one coming, and no one would have known to look for her, because as far as anyone outside that house knew, she had simply gone to visit her mother-in-law and not come back, and people do not always notice right away when a woman does not come back, and by the time they do, it can be too late.
And Emily would have been gone before dawn. That is the part I cannot get past. Emily, six years old, locked in a pantry, would have been taken out of that house in the dark and put into a car and driven away, and her mother would have been tied to a post in a basement and her grandmother would have been in a trash bin on the curb, and there would have been no one left to say where she had gone or who had taken her. Tom and Mark would have had the whole night to disappear, and the whole morning, and by the time the police were called, the trail would have been cold, and a six-year-old girl would have been gone, and the people who loved her most would have been the people who could not help her, because they were the ones who had been hurt first.