Linda was interviewed too, separately, in a different room, with the detective nearby and her advocate beside her. I did not see it happen. I read about it afterward, and I have thought about her words many times since. Her wrists were still bandaged when she spoke. I keep coming back to that detail, because it makes the whole thing real in a way nothing else does. Bandages. On her wrists. In an interview room, under fluorescent lights, with a cup of water in front of her that she did not drink. She said, "When my husband started telling people I was forgetful, I thought he was embarrassed by me. ... I didn't understand he was building a story before he needed it." I read that sentence three times when I first saw it, and then I read it again, and I understood something I had not understood before. Tom had not simply been cruel. He had been careful. He had been laying the groundwork, telling the neighbors, telling the family, telling anyone who would listen, that his wife was losing her memory, that she was confused, that she could not be trusted, that she wandered, that she forgot things. And each time he said it, it became a little more true in other people's minds, not because it was true, but because he had said it so many times, and because nobody had any reason to doubt a husband talking about his wife. He was building a story before he needed it. He was building it so that when the day came that she disappeared, or was found somewhere she should not have been, or said something that contradicted him, everyone would already have an explanation ready. She was forgetful. She was confused. She was not reliable. And the terrible thing was that it worked, for a while. It worked on me. I had heard him say it, and I had not questioned it, and I had thought, well, she is getting older, and that is sad, and I had moved on with my day. I had not asked her. I had not looked at her wrists. I had not wondered why a woman who was supposedly so confused still kept her house so clean and her garden so neat and her granddaughter's drawings on the refrigerator in such careful rows.
When the reporter asked Linda what she remembered most from inside the bin, she said, "The lid opening ... I thought I was going to die under Christmas garbage bags. Then I saw her face." Her face. My face. She meant me. I have thought about that, too, more than I can say. I was the first face she saw when the lid opened, and she thought she was going to die, and then she saw me, and she knew she was not going to die, or at least she hoped she was not, and that moment has stayed with me ever since. I did not do anything extraordinary that night. I climbed a ladder. I held a string of lights. I looked over a fence. I saw something wrong and I did not walk away from it. That is all. But to Linda, in the dark, under the garbage bags, with her wrists taped together, that was everything. A face. A person who had seen her. A person who was not going to pretend she was not there. I think about that when I am tempted to think that ordinary people cannot do anything that matters. We can. We can look. We can stay. We can open a lid. It does not take a hero. It takes a neighbor who does not look away.
The following Saturday, Linda came back to the neighborhood for an hour. She was brought by a detective, in an unmarked car, and she carried a small paper angel ornament in her hands, the kind a child makes in school with folded paper and glitter that gets everywhere. She had made it, or Emily had made it, I never asked which, and she held it the whole time as if it were something precious, which it was. We had decided, Paul and I, and Mr. Rhodes, and Mrs. Patel, and a few others, that we would finish the lights together. Not for a photograph. Not for the news. Just because the lights had been left half hung and the house had been dark and it felt wrong to leave it that way, and because Linda was coming back for an hour and we wanted her to see something bright when she arrived.