I thought about the night Paul and I had talked it over, the night before we started decorating, because that conversation had mattered more than I realized at the time. We had been sitting at the kitchen table with the calendar open, and Paul had said, "Let's do it early this year," and I had said, "Early? We never do it early," and he had said, "I know. That's why I want to do it early." And we had looked at each other, and we had not needed to say the rest, because the rest was there between us, in the quiet of the kitchen, in the way his hand found mine across the table. We were not decorating early because we loved Christmas more than we had the year before. We were decorating early because we needed the yard to be ours again before the anniversary of that night crept up on us and took it from us a second time. And Paul, who teaches history to teenagers and knows better than anyone how anniversaries work, how they come around every year whether you are ready or not, had understood that, and had said it out loud, and I had loved him for saying it, and for not pretending it was about the weather.
And I thought about the neighbors who had stopped by while we were hanging the lights, because they had, one by one, the way neighbors do when they see someone out in the yard in December. Mrs. Alvarez from down the street had come out to her porch and waved, and called out that the lights looked beautiful, and I had waved back, and it had felt like a real thing, a real exchange between real people, not the careful nods we had given each other for most of the year. And the man from two doors down, the one who had stood in his driveway that terrible night and watched the police cars come and go, had stopped on his walk and said the house was looking good, and Paul had thanked him, and they had talked about the cold, and about the holidays, ordinary talk, the kind of talk that holds a neighborhood together, and I had listened to it from the ladder and thought, this is how it comes back, not all at once, but in pieces, in waves and hellos and talk about the cold.
I thought about dinner, too, because Linda and Rachel and Emily had stayed for dinner, and it had not been planned, and that was the best part of it, that it had not been planned. Paul had gone out and gotten a rotisserie chicken from the store, and I had made mashed potatoes, and Linda had brought out the rest of the cookies, and we had all sat around the table, the five of us, with the tree lit in the next room, and Emily had eaten two helpings and told us about school, about her teacher, about a book she was reading, about a friend who had lost a tooth the same week she had lost hers, and she had talked and talked, the way children do when they feel safe, and Rachel had laughed, a real laugh, and Linda had reached across the table and squeezed my hand, and I had understood that this, this ordinary dinner, this chicken and potatoes and a child talking too much, was the thing we had all been fighting for, in our different ways, for a year.
And I thought about Emily's year, because a year is a long time in the life of a child, and she had lived a whole one since that December, a year of school and friends and losing a front tooth and growing taller, and I thought about how children carry things differently than adults do, how they do not carry them in their shoulders the way we do, or in their sleep the way we do, but in small questions asked at unexpected moments, in the way they line up their boots by the door, in the way they hold a paper angel with both hands as if it might break. And I thought about how careful we have to be with that, how careful we have to be with children who have seen too much, and how the best thing we can do for them is not to hide the truth from them, but to tell it to them straight, in words they can hold, the way I had told Emily the truth on the couch, that we are watching out for each other now, and how she had nodded, and leaned against me, and how that nod had been worth more than a thousand reassurances.