The morning had been so normal that it hurt to think about it now. We had woken up to a thin skin of frost on the car windshields and a sky the color of pale pewter, and Paul had made coffee the way he always did, too strong, and we had eaten toast standing up in the kitchen because neither of us wanted to sit down and admit that the day had started. It was the first Saturday in December, and all up and down the street people were putting up their Christmas lights, because that was what our street did, every year, on the first Saturday, as if by some unspoken agreement. The Hendersons had their icicle lights already strung along the gutters. Mrs. Delaney had her wooden reindeer out on the lawn. Paul had dragged the ladder out of the garage before breakfast and spent an hour untangling the strings of lights in the driveway, cursing under his breath in the patient, good-natured way he cursed when he was doing something he secretly enjoyed, and I had carried the garland out to him, and we had been laughing, actually laughing, about the year the lights had shorted out the whole block and the electrician had come on Christmas Eve. That was the morning. Toast and coffee and tangled lights and laughter. And then Tom Halvorsen came out of his house carrying a blanket with a hand in it, and the whole day split open like a cracked egg.
I thought about Linda then, the way you think about a person when you are afraid you are about to lose them. I thought about her gray-blonde hair, always pinned back neatly, and the way she waved from her porch every morning when I walked past with the groceries, a small wave, just the fingers, as if she did not want to make a fuss of it. I thought about the plate of shortbread she had brought us last Christmas, still warm from the oven, wrapped in foil, and the way she had stood on our doorstep apologizing for it, as if bringing your neighbors cookies were something to apologize for. I thought about her garden in the summer, the rows of marigolds and the tomato plants staked up with string, and the way she talked to them, softly, when she thought no one was listening. She was a quiet woman. That was what everyone said about her. Quiet, and kind, and private. She kept to herself. She did not make a fuss. And now she was folded into a blanket in her own driveway, and her husband was looking up and down the street like a man checking whether anyone had seen him commit a crime.
And the slipper. I thought about the slipper then, too. I had seen it that morning when I carried the garland out to Paul, a single slipper lying on its side on the walkway in front of the Halvorsens' house, pale blue, fur-lined, one of a pair, and I had registered it in the idle way you register things that do not concern you, the way you notice a lost glove on a park bench or a newspaper left out in the rain. It had seemed strange for half a second. Who loses one slipper on their own walkway? And then I had forgotten it entirely, because the lights needed hanging and the garland needed untangling and there was coffee to finish. Now the slipper was back in my mind, bright and sharp, and I understood what it meant. It meant that whatever had happened in that house had happened in a hurry. It meant that someone had been taken, or had run, or had fought, and a slipper had come off in the struggle, and no one had stopped to pick it up.
Paul was still up on the ladder. I heard myself say his name, but it came out wrong, thin and high, not like my voice at all. "Paul." He didn't turn. He was holding the string of lights with both hands, his head tilted back, and he said something about the clip not holding, something ordinary, and I said his name again, louder, and this time it broke open in my throat and came out as a shout that I did not recognize. "Paul! The bin! Look at the bin!"
He turned then. He looked where I was pointing, and I saw his face change the way a face changes when a car swerves into your lane, that blank half-second before the fear arrives. He came down the ladder so fast he skipped the last two rungs and landed hard on the grass, and the string of lights swung and hit the porch rail and one of the bulbs popped with a sound like a knuckle cracking. He was already moving across the yard, and I was moving too, my feet slipping on the frost-slick grass, the coil of garland still in my hands because I had forgotten to put it down, and all I could think, over and over, was that the hand had moved, the hand had moved, and Tom Halvorsen was standing in his driveway with a blanket wrapped around a person.