I keep thinking about the lights. I keep thinking about Paul standing on the ladder and me holding the string of lights and handing them up to him, one after another, the way we have done it every year, and the cold air on my face and the sound of our voices in the dark, and how ordinary it all was. We were not being brave. We were not being heroes. We were hanging Christmas lights. We were doing the most ordinary thing in the world, on the most ordinary night, and because we were outside, because we were standing in our yard in the dark with a string of lights in our hands, we saw something we were not supposed to see, and that something turned out to be the difference between a woman living and a woman dying in a trash bin on a Monday morning.
I do not know what to do with that. I have tried to make it into a lesson, because that is what people do when something terrible happens and they need it to mean something, but it does not feel like a lesson. It feels like luck. It feels like the worst kind of luck and the best kind of luck at the same time, the kind of luck that makes you grateful and sick in the same breath, because you understand that if the luck had gone the other way, three people would have been destroyed, and you would never have known, and you would have gone on hanging your lights and living your life and never understanding what had happened two doors down.
I think about that every time I look at our house now. I think about how thin the line was. I think about how many nights Paul and I have stayed inside, how many Sundays we have said we would do the lights tomorrow, how many small decisions we have made without thinking about them, and I think about how one of those small decisions, made without any thought at all, turned out to be the one that mattered. And I think about Linda, and about Rachel, and about Emily, and I think about how close they came to being lost, and I am grateful in a way that does not feel like gratitude at all, but like something heavier, something that sits in my chest and does not go away.
The police searched the house after that, and they found Mark hiding in the attic above the garage. I did not see them bring him out. I heard about it later, the way I heard about most of it, and I have tried to picture it, the officers going up into the attic with their flashlights, the dust and the insulation and the cold, and Mark crouched up there in the dark, listening to them come closer, waiting to see if they would find him. He had been living in that house for nearly a week, in the basement and then in the attic, moving through the rooms of his parents' home like a ghost, and when the police finally came for him, he was hiding above the garage, above the cars, above the place where his father parked every day and waved at the neighbors, and he was waiting to see if he could wait them out.
They found more than Mark up there. They found a packed child's suitcase. I have thought about that suitcase more than almost anything else, because a packed child's suitcase is not an accident. It is not something you pack by mistake. It is a small suitcase, packed with a child's clothes, packed carefully, packed by someone who knew exactly what a six-year-old girl would need and how long she would need it for, and it was sitting in the attic above the garage, waiting, the way Mark had been waiting, the way the whole plan had been waiting, for the moment when they could take Emily out of that house and disappear.
They found cash. They found burner phones, more than one, the kind of phones you buy when you do not want anyone to know who you are calling or where you are. They found a printed route map from Washington to Idaho. I have held that detail in my mind and turned it over and over, the way you turn over a stone you found on the ground, because it tells you everything about what they were planning. Washington to Idaho. A route, printed out on paper, so they would not have to rely on a phone that could be tracked. A route that crossed a state line, which makes everything harder, which makes it harder for the police to follow and harder for a mother to find her child and harder for a court to undo what has been done. They were not planning to take Emily for a visit. They were not planning to take her for a weekend. They were planning to take her across a state line and disappear with her, and they had the suitcase and the cash and the phones and the map ready, and the only thing standing between them and that plan was a grandmother who came home early from shopping and a neighbor who went outside to hang Christmas lights.