They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The evidence was overwhelming. That is the phrase the prosecutor used, and for once the phrase was not an exaggeration. There was the tape. Paul had handed it over the night of the rescue, still in its plastic, and I remember the way the officer took it from him with both hands, the way you take something fragile, and put it in an evidence bag and sealed it, and the sound the seal made, a small tearing sound that somehow felt final. There was the note, the one Rachel had left behind, or the one Emily had written, I never did learn which hand had held the pen first, only that the words were a child's words and the fear in them was not a child's fear, it was a grown fear that had been handed down. There was the broken phone, gathered from the garage floor in pieces, each piece bagged separately, as if the phone itself had been a person and the pieces were its remains. There was the child's suitcase, small and pink, packed in a hurry, with clothes folded the wrong way, the way a child folds when she is scared and trying to be brave at the same time. There was the route map, the one Tom had drawn or printed, with the roads marked and the towns circled, a plan laid out in ink, which meant it had not been a moment of madness, it had been a decision, made in advance, thought through, and that was worse, somehow, than if it had been sudden. And there were the neighbors' testimonies, ours and others', people who had heard things and seen things and had not put them together until the night the bin was opened. And there was the trash bin itself, which sat at the curb for two days after the arrests, green and dented and ordinary, until the police came and took it away as evidence, loading it into a truck with the same care they had taken with the tape, and I stood at my window and watched it go, and I thought about how strange it was that something so ordinary could hold something so terrible, and how the street looked wrong without it and also looked right, because it should never have been there in the first place.

The Halvorsen house was dark after the arrests. I mean that literally. The lights were off. The porch light, which had always been on, was off. The windows were black. The driveway was empty. The house stood there like a mouth closed tight, and nobody went near it, and nobody wanted to. I used to look at it when I came home from work, and I would think about Linda inside it all those months, and about Rachel, and about Emily, and about how a house can look perfectly normal from the street while something awful is happening behind its walls. I had walked past that house a hundred times. I had waved at Tom in the driveway. I had said hello to Linda at the mailbox. I had never once imagined what was happening inside. That is the part that stayed with me, long after the arrests, long after the bin was taken away. Not the horror of what happened, but the ordinariness of it. The house looked like every other house on the street. The lawn was mowed. The gutters were clean. The trash was taken out on schedule. And inside, a woman was being told she was forgetful, being told she was confused, being told she was a burden, until she almost believed it herself.

Paul and I gave one interview. Just one. We did not want to talk to the press at all, and for weeks we said no, politely, firmly, to every reporter who called or knocked on the door. But Linda asked us to. She asked us through the detective, and then she asked us herself, on the phone, in a voice that was still thin and careful, as if she were testing each word before she let it out. She said she wanted people to know what had happened, not the version with the Christmas lights in the headline, but the real version, the one that started long before that night. She said she was tired of being a story other people told wrong. So we sat down in our living room, Paul and I, with a reporter from the local paper, a young woman with a notebook and a tape recorder, and we told her what we had seen. We did not exaggerate. We did not perform. We just told it plainly, the way it had happened, and the reporter wrote it down, and when the article came out it was mostly right, which was more than I had expected.

News in the same category

They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

45 Part