They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

Chapter 37

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The interview we gave, the one Linda asked for, took place on a Tuesday afternoon in our living room, and the reporter was younger than I expected, and she was nervous, and she kept apologizing for her questions, and I liked her for that. She asked us what we had seen, and we told her, and she asked us how we felt, and Paul said he felt angry, and I said I felt sad, and she asked us what we wanted people to know, and I said I wanted people to know that Linda was not forgetful, that she was not confused, that she had been telling the truth all along and nobody had listened, and that the reason nobody had listened was that her husband had told them not to, in so many words, over so many months, that they had stopped hearing her at all. The reporter wrote that down. When the article came out, it was on the front page of the local paper, below the fold, with a photograph of our street in the snow, and I read it twice, and Paul read it once, and we did not talk about it afterward, because there was nothing to say. It was done. Linda had asked us to speak, and we had spoken, and that was that.

Linda's own interview stayed with me longer than ours did, because of the bandages, and because of the sentence about building a story before he needed it. I thought about that sentence for weeks. I thought about all the times Tom had told me, casually, at the mailbox, over the fence, that Linda was getting forgetful, that she had left the stove on, that she had forgotten where she put her keys, that she had wandered down to the end of the street and not known how to get back. I had believed him. I had no reason not to. He was her husband. He was a neighbor. He seemed concerned. And now I knew that each of those small stories had been a brick, and he had been building a wall with them, a wall between Linda and the rest of us, so that when the day came that she needed us, we would already have decided she was not worth believing. That is the most frightening part of all of this, to me. Not the bin. The bin was terrible, but the bin was one night. The wall was months. The wall was built slowly, in daylight, in ordinary conversations, with a concerned expression and a shake of the head, and nobody noticed it going up, because it did not look like a wall. It looked like a husband talking about his wife. And that is why Linda's sentence matters so much. "I didn't understand he was building a story before he needed it." She did not understand it at the time. Neither did I. But we understand it now, and understanding it changes the way I listen to people. When someone tells me, over and over, that another person is unreliable, I ask myself why they are telling me. I ask myself what they might need me to believe, and when they might need me to believe it. That is a hard way to live, always questioning, always wondering, but it is better than the alternative, which is believing a story that was built to hide a crime.

The Saturday when Linda came back, with the detective and the paper angel, was cold, and the sky was the color of old pewter, and the sun went down early, the way it does in winter. I remember Mrs. Patel's hot chocolate, and the steam, and the way the teenagers sat on the curb untangling the lights, and the way Mr. Rhodes coiled his extension cord, and the way the Santa figure's belly lit up red when someone plugged him in. I remember Linda standing in the driveway, holding the angel, looking at the house, and saying, "That we're still here." I remember thinking that she was right, and that the lights were proof, and that proof matters, not just in courtrooms, but in driveways, on winter evenings, when a woman who was put in a trash bin comes back to her street and sees her neighbors standing in the cold, holding extension cords and thermoses, putting up lights for her. That is proof, too. That is evidence, too. It does not go in a folder. It does not get sealed in a bag. But it counts. It counts more than almost anything else, because it is the proof that the story Tom built did not win. The neighborhood did not believe it, not in the end. The neighborhood looked, and listened, and remembered, and showed up, and that is what being a neighborhood means. It is not about the houses. It is about the people who come out in the cold with extension cords.

News in the same category

They Were Hanging Christmas Lights When They Saw Their Neighbor Put His Wife Into the Trash Bin

45 Part