Two Small Moons

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

For twenty-six years she had kept it exactly where she was told grief belonged. She lit a candle every May the ninth, in the window of the back room, and she said nothing to anyone, and in her heart she called the lost baby by the name she had chosen in the last weeks of the pregnancy, lying awake beside Richard with both girls moving under her hands like fish under ice — the name that had never once passed her lips, never been written, never been given to the air. She thought of it now, standing in her kitchen at the age of fifty-eight, and did not say it. Some things she was still not ready to spend.

But there was the question. It rose out of the order of things as she walked, and it stood in the kitchen doorway with its arms folded, the way it had stood for twenty-five years: the question she had asked exactly once.

Belle had been a year old. It was the summer of 2001, a bath night, the kitchen sink because the tub was being re-grouted, Belle slippery and outraged and shining in the warm water, and the little moon on her wrist had come up dark against her wet skin the way it always did when she was warm. Catherine's mother had been there, or a neighbor had — memory kept the audience vague and kept the moment itself in amber — and somebody had laughed and said, *That child is marked for the sea, look at that,* and the moon had sailed on Belle's wrist through the bathwater, and that night, in bed, in the dark, Catherine had asked it as carefully as she had ever asked anything.

"Richard. Did the other one — did she have it too? The mark. Did she have Belle's mark?"

He had not hesitated. That was what she remembered now with her whole body: he had not hesitated for one breath.

"No," he said. "I saw her, Catherine. There was no mark on that child."

And the air in the room had gone arctic, not with anger — with finality, with the sound a vault makes — and she had understood that the question had been admitted once and would not be admitted again, and she had never asked it again. For twenty-five years she had filed his answer in the locked room with the candle and the name, and it had kept its edge all that time, *I saw her*, and she had simply never taken it out and looked at what it was made of.

Now it was out. Now it lay on the kitchen table between the baby book and the telephone, and it was made of this: Richard had seen the dead baby. Richard had looked at her, closely enough to know about a mark the size of a thumbnail on the inside of a wrist. Richard had been very, very sure.

And this morning — *yesterday* morning, she corrected herself, because it was past midnight now, because the house had gone into the small hours around her without her noticing — a girl had poured her water in a restaurant in Portland, a girl of twenty-six with a foundling's papers and a birthday given to her by strangers, and on the inside of her left wrist, below the heel of her hand, horns up, the size of a thumbnail, there had been a small pale moon.

If Richard's dead baby had no mark, then the girl was a stranger, and this was a coincidence of the kind the world produced the way the sea produced identical shells — and Catherine could go upstairs now, and sleep, and tell no one, and in a year be unable to remember why she had sat up half the night.

If Richard's dead baby had no mark —

Catherine stood in the kitchen a long time with the two sentences facing each other like duelists, and she knew, with the part of herself that had never once in fifty-eight years been wrong about the weather inside her own house, which of them was holding the real gun.

She did not go upstairs. She sat down at the kitchen table, and she opened the baby book to its last blank page, and she took the pen that lived in the drawer with the string and the batteries and the household's small necessities. Her hand was steady. Twenty-six years the back of the book had waited, blank as snow, for a record she had never been permitted to make.

News in the same category

Two Small Moons

45 Part