Two Small Moons

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

She touched the delivery summary. "This proves that on the ninth of May, 2000, you delivered twin girls at St. Brigid's, that the clinic recorded one as living and one as stillborn, and that Dr. Alcott signed the record. Records can lie, Catherine, but they lie for reasons — and a record also simply errs, more often than any of us likes to think."

She touched the ledger page. "This proves that two days later, St. Brigid's Clinic transferred a healthy newborn girl to the Children's Home, with no parent named, and that she bore the same mark you saw on your daughter's wrist — and on your other daughter's wrist, in the one minute you were permitted to see her. And this—" the cemetery printouts, "—proves that the Hollis family recorded a dead infant and never buried one. There is no burial, no cremation record, no permit. There is a story of a burial. The burial itself is missing."

"And what does it not prove," Catherine said.

"It does not prove that the child in the ledger is your child. It does not prove that the child you were told died, died. It does not prove a crime, or who knew what, or when. There may be explanations I cannot imagine, standing in the wreckage of two closed institutions and a quarter-century of lost paper. A mislabeled transfer. Another mother, another tragedy, arriving at the same clinic on the same night with a marked child of her own." Diane folded her hands. "I assign that possibility a very low weight, Catherine. But it exists, and you must know it exists. There is a test, of course. DNA doesn't care about any of our stories. Yours, and the girl's, and your daughter's. It would answer the question to a moral certainty in a fortnight."

Catherine said nothing.

"Which brings me," Diane said, "to the question underneath all the other questions, the only one that is entirely yours. What do you intend to do with the truth?"

"I intend to—" Catherine began, and stopped.

"Consider it carefully. If Nora Quinn is your daughter, then she has a mother who was told she was dead, and a father who arranged a great many things in May of 2000 and has forbidden the subject for twenty-six years, and a twin sister who grew up an only child in a house with a grief in it like a fourth chair at the table. She has a name she was given by strangers and a birthday the home assigned her that happens — happens — to be the true one. She has a life, Catherine, and by all you've told me she has made a decent one. The truth will not arrive in her life like weather. It will arrive like a wrecking ball. And it cannot be un-known. So. Do you want to know — only to know? Do you want her told? Do you want her back? Those are three different wars, and I will not march you into any of them until you can tell me which one we're fighting.

"I have been a mother with an empty chair for twenty-six years," Catherine said at last, "and I trained myself not to look at the chair. Last week I looked up from a cup of coffee and the chair was occupied by a living woman who did not know my name. You ask me what I intend to do with the truth, Diane. I intend, first, to have it. Really have it — not a story I was handed in a hospital corridor by a husband fighting for his company with both hands. Then I intend to ask her what she wants done with it. She is the only person in this whole miserable arrangement who has never once been asked anything. They didn't ask her when they wrote 'no parental information.' Whatever we do, she gets asked. First, and with the whole of it in front of her. That's my answer."

Diane looked at her for a long moment, then nodded, once, like a judge and like a friend in one motion. "Then we proceed," she said. "In order. The records first, all of them, everywhere. Then Dr. Alcott — he's eighty-four and retired, and men of eighty-four sometimes decide that the truth has kept long enough. Then, when we are certain — only when we are certain — we think about the girl." She gathered the pages into their folder. "Go home, Catherine. And the folder stays here, in my safe. Not because I don't trust you. Because paper in a house has a way of being found by exactly the person it would most injure."

Richard noticed on the second morning.

He noticed the way he noticed everything: not by looking for it, but by registering that the entries had changed. Catherine was late to breakfast, which she never was. She had dressed with more care than a Thursday required. She ate nothing, and drank her coffee standing at the window — and Richard Hollis, who had read men across negotiating tables for forty years, read his wife, set down his newspaper, and chose the managerial approach: gentle, reasonable, and pointed like a compass needle.

News in the same category

Two Small Moons

45 Part