Two Small Moons

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

every part of it, and I let it happen, which from the inside feels exactly like arranging it and photographs the same. Within the week I took the true page out of the delivery ledger — the ledger was bound, Mrs. Hollis, I had to work the stitching loose with a scalpel, in my office, at night, like a thief in my own hospital — and I kept it. I have kept it for twenty-six years, through my retirement, through my wife's death, through the sale of our house, into this room. I kept the evidence of the one dishonest act of my life, against myself, in a drawer I open perhaps once a year. People will tell you that means something noble. It does not. It means I could not destroy it and I could not use it, and a man who can do neither becomes a drawer himself. Things are kept in him, shut, in the dark, in order."

"You will have more than paper," he said, after a moment, and it was the first thing he had asked for himself. "The records end at the home's door. I have wondered — I permitted myself to wonder, which is not the same as permitting myself to know — whether anyone ever learned what became of her. After the eleventh of May."

"She lived," Catherine said. "She is twenty-six years old. She waits tables in Portland. She has her sister's health and her sister's mark and, until we can give it back to her, somebody else's name." She said it evenly, as a fact among facts, because she had sworn the girl would get all of them at once and she was not going to start spending them here, in this room, ahead of time. "We found her through your paper, Dr. Alcott. Yours and the home's. The mark did the rest."

"Then she lived," he said, and closed his eyes for a moment, not in prayer — in the plain receipt of a fact he had denied himself for twenty-six years. "I allowed myself not to know even that. You must understand that it was not indifference. It was the last of the mercies I arranged for myself, and I arranged it daily, the way other men arrange their pills."

Catherine had not moved. Diane's pen had stopped moving some time before, and she had let it stop, which for Diane was an act of respect Catherine would remember later.

"Did I hold her?" Catherine asked.

It was the first question she had asked him, and it went through the room like weather through a door left open.

"No," Alcott said. "You held Belle, the next day. The other — " He stopped himself, and corrected, with care. "Your elder daughter was taken to the nursery while you slept, and out of your life before you were fully awake in it. You never held her. I have always known that would be the question. It is the right one. I am sorry that the answer is mine to give."

For a while there was only the sound of the building being a building — a door somewhere, water in a pipe, the ordinary machinery of a place where old people are kept kindly while they finish.

"There is more in the drawer," Diane said, at last, in her work voice, gently. "Isn't there, Dr. Alcott."

"There is the page," he said. "And the photograph. And — " a pause in which something almost like shame crossed him, the first unguarded thing of the morning "— and the statements. I have drafted a statement eleven times in twenty-six years. I counted them once, in a bad winter. Eleven statements, Mrs. Hollis, each one complete, each one true, each one fit to end the lie and several of them fit to end me. A statement is a door a man builds in his own wall. I built it eleven times. I never once walked through it. They are in the drawer too, if your attorney wants the archaeology of a cowardice. The later ones are shorter. A man runs out of ways to say it, and then he finds the short way is the only way, and still he doesn't send it."

He reached — slowly, giving them time to understand the movement — to the desk drawer beside his chair, and opened it, and took out a folder that had once been manila and was now the color of weak tea, and laid it on his knees, and opened it with the care of a man handling something that had been asleep.

The page was a single sheet, ruled, torn — no, worked — from a bound book, the stitch-holes still visible along its left edge like the perforations of a held breath. His handwriting, younger then, slanted and certain. He did not hand it over at once. He read it aloud, because reading it aloud was clearly an appointment he had made with himself long ago.

News in the same category

Two Small Moons

45 Part