Two Small Moons

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"He did not raise his voice. Men like Richard never do; it is the whole of their training. He spoke about the trust his father had settled — I will not pretend to reproduce its terms, which were legal and intricate and which he explained to me as if to a child: what a second daughter did to the succession, what the trustees would require, what his lenders would make of a family complication in a year when his affairs were balanced the way a plate is balanced, on a finger. He spoke about Belle — the living daughter, the one the world was to be told about — as if she were a settlement already reached. And he had an envelope in the inside pocket of the coat he had never taken off, which he did not trouble to hide.

"And then, at the end, quite gently, he mentioned a case of mine. Six years before. A delivery that went wrong in its final minutes, a mother and a child I could not save both of, and a settlement that was sealed, and a board that had been satisfied. It was the worst night of my professional life, and it was closed, and it was the kind of file that ends a man if it is ever read aloud in the wrong room. Richard knew of it. I never learned how. Men of his kind collect such knowledge the way other men collect weather — against the day it rains."

The cardinal had gone from the feeder. Down the hall, the cart came back the other way.

"He said: the smaller child is very small, Doctor. The night is very bad. These things happen. A stillbirth is a sorrow a family can bury. He did not say the other words. No one ever says the other words." Alcott looked down at his hands, which he had set flat again, deliberately, the way a man sets down something breakable. "I refused him in that corridor. I want that recorded too, though it defends nothing — a refusal that lasts eleven minutes is a courtesy a man pays himself. Because then I stood there and I did the arithmetic that cowards do and call it grief. The sealed case, opened, was the end of me — not only of my practice. Of the name. Of everything I had built since I was a boy who wanted to deliver babies because it was the one room in medicine where the news was usually good. I had a wife. I had a daughter. I had eleven thousand — " He shook his head, once. "No. That comes later. I did the arithmetic, and the sum came out as my life against a stranger's, and I chose mine. I went back into the ward, and I wrote the true page first — I have never known whether that was conscience or cowardice keeping an alibi — and then I signed the summary that the clinic keeps to this day: one live birth, one stillbirth, attending H. Alcott. The summary named her as the second-born, Mrs. Hollis, and dead in the same breath. Even that was part of the lie. She was not the second. She was the first. She was the elder of your daughters, and the record I signed made her the younger and the dead one, because a dead second twin is a tidier sorrow than a stolen first one.

"I have delivered eleven thousand babies, Mrs. Hollis. I lied about one. I chose to."

He said it to her face and he did not look away after he said it, and Catherine understood that this, too, was a discipline — that he had denied himself the mercy of the floor, the window, the ceiling, all the places a man's eyes go when he is asking to be forgiven without saying so. He was not asking. That was the whole of his dignity and the whole of his indictment, in one gesture: he was not asking.

"Two days later," he said, "on the eleventh of May, she was taken from the clinic by a nurse on my staff, whose name I will not give you, because her accounting is her own and I will not spend another person's soul to lighten mine — and she was left at St. Brigid's Children's Home as a foundling, with a blanket and nothing else. No name. The mark on her wrist unexplained. I did not arrange every part of it. I knew of

News in the same category

Two Small Moons

45 Part