The book itself was blue cloth, the gilt on its spine worn to a ghost. BELLE, it said, in the hopeful capitals of a woman of thirty-two who had believed she was beginning a set. Inside, her own young handwriting came up at her off page after page like a voice from the bottom of a well: the hospital bracelet, taped in. The first photograph, Belle in a knitted cap too large for her, frowning at the world with unconcealed suspicion. A lock of hair the color of pennies, in its envelope. Weight, length, the hour of her birth — recorded with the reverence of a ship's log. First smile, first tooth, first word (*moon*, Belle's first word had been moon, said to the window over the sink at fourteen months, and the whole family had laughed, and Catherine's handwriting had underlined it twice). And then the entries thinning as the years filled — school, the lake, the lost front teeth — and stopping altogether, as baby books do, somewhere in the country of Belle at five, mid-sentence, because life had outrun the recording of it.
She turned to the back of the book. The last pages were blank. They had been blank for twenty-six years, bought and paid for and never used, the space where the record of a second daughter should have gone.
Catherine sat with the blank pages open under the kitchen light for a while. Then she took out her telephone.
She needed a pretext, and she found one the way she found everything, by reaching for the nearest true thing that was not the truth: she was rehanging the upstairs landing, she told Belle — she had decided at last to do the family wall properly, frames, no more of that leaning business — and she wanted the photograph from last summer, the one at the lake. "The one where you're laughing," Catherine said. "You know the one."
"Mom, I sent you that already. Like, twice."
"Send it a third time. Indulge me."
Belle, who was twenty-six and busy and in possession of a life that did not run on her mother's rails, sighed the sigh of the beloved young, and the photographs arrived while they were still talking, three of them in a bright little cascade. Catherine said the correct things. She asked about the project, the apartment, the young man whose name had recently begun appearing in the way names appear when they are going to matter. She did not ask about anything else, because there was nothing else she could ask that would not be overheard by the entire future.
When the call ended she sat in the quiet kitchen and opened the lake photograph and made it large with two fingers.
Belle, laughing, last summer, on the dock with the sun going down behind her in a blaze that turned the whole lake to hammered copper. Belle in a white shirt with the sleeves pushed up. Belle with her head thrown back at something outside the frame, her throat bare, entirely unguarded — and her left arm flung out along the dock rail, wrist turned up to the light as carelessly as a girl turns a page, and there, on the inside of it, below the heel of her hand, pale as a scar that had decided to be beautiful instead: the crescent. Horns up. The size of a thumbnail. A small moon, risen and set in her daughter's skin.
Catherine held the telephone beside her memory of a restaurant in Portland, and she looked, and she looked. The memory did not blur to protect her. It stood its ground in perfect detail, because it was barely a day old and because she had been attending to it with her whole soul: the reach across the table, the glass raised, the wrist turning up into the noon light — the same wrist, the same place on the wrist, the same small moon with its horns turned up like a cup. Not similar. She turned the word over with the care of a woman who had kept books for a shipping firm in her youth and knew what words were worth. Not *similar*. The same, the way a signature is the same. The way a face is the same across a room after forty years.
She put the telephone face-down on the table, gently, the way you set down something that might go off.
Twenty feet away, across the dark of the hall, was the window of the back room, where the candle lived. It was not May the ninth, so the window was dark, but Catherine could have found that sill blindfolded; she had found it in the dark twenty-six times. Every year of Belle's life, the ninth of May had been two days wearing one coat. In the front of the house: a birthday — balloons when Belle was small, then dinners, then, in the lean