She had been wrong about the reason for the seal. That was all. She was going to be wrong about it for approximately four more hours.
Catherine arrived at the museum at twenty past two, unannounced, on a Tuesday.
Belle saw her from the archive room doorway and knew before her mother had said a word that something had come apart. Catherine Hollis did not make unannounced visits; she arrived the way weather fronts were announced, with notice, so that people could prepare the version of themselves she expected to find. She was fifty-eight and beautiful in the disciplined way of a woman who had decided early that composure was armor, and she stood in the museum's front hall in a gray coat, a document case against her side, and her face was not composed at all.
"Mother." Belle came down the short stairs. "Is it Father?"
"No." Catherine's voice was steady and very quiet. "Your father is well. Everyone is — " She stopped, and did the thing Belle had never in her life seen her do: she looked around the public hall as though deciding whether the truth could be said in it, and found that it could not. "Is there a room where we can sit down? Somewhere that is only ours for an hour."
Belle took her to the reading room, where the long oak table ran under the tall windows and the ship logs lay in their gray boxes along the shelves. She shut the door. She did not offer tea; her mother would not have been able to drink it. Catherine sat down and laid the document case flat in front of her, and rested both hands on it for a moment, the way a swimmer rests hands on the edge before committing to cold water.
"I am going to tell you this in order," Catherine said, "because order is the only kindness I can still do it in. I will not soften it. If I soften it, I will find a place to stop, and I have been stopping for twenty-six years."
"All right."
"Three weeks ago," Catherine said, "I asked the clinic for your birth records. All of them. I told them it was for insurance. It was not for insurance. When you were born I was ill for a long time afterward — you know that. What you do not know is that there were whole days of that spring I have never been able to account for, and this year I became unwilling to leave them unaccounted. So I asked for the records. And then I asked St. Brigid's for theirs."
"St. Brigid's," Belle said. "The children's home."
"Yes."
Her mother opened the case. "You were born on the ninth of May, 2000, at twenty past six in the evening. You weighed six pounds two ounces. Your sister was born forty minutes after you. She weighed four pounds nine ounces." The word sister, spoken in that room, in that voice, altered the temperature of the air; Belle felt it happen and said nothing. "The clinic's record says she died before midnight. Failure to thrive — that is the phrase it uses. It was the phrase your father used to me, in the corridor, the one time it was ever discussed. I was not well. I believed what I was told by the people standing around my bed, all of whom were being paid, in one way or another, by your father."
"Mother — "
"In order, Belle. Please." Catherine's hands stayed flat on the case. "There is no burial. I want you to hear that the way I heard it — from a clerk, over a telephone, in a voice that apologized twice. There is no burial permit. There is no grave, in any cemetery, in any record I have been able to reach, and I have reached all of them. A baby died in that clinic on the ninth of May, 2000, according to one page. And no baby was buried. The dead do not simply fail to be filed, Belle. Someone files them. That is what the world does with its dead. It files them."
"And St. Brigid's," she said.
"On the eleventh of May, 2000 — two days after you were born — St. Brigid's Children's Home received a foundling. A girl. Brought in at night, no name, no note, no person who stayed to give an account of her. The intake record gives her age as approximately two days. It gives her weight as four pounds nine ounces." Catherine opened the case then, and took out the copies — clinic pages, home pages, clipped in sequence, the way Belle herself would have clipped them — and laid them in a row. "And it describes, in the nurse's hand, on the line for distinguishing marks, a birthmark. On the inside of the left wrist. Pale. Crescent-shaped. The nurse wrote: like a small moon."