Catherine had not spoken for some time. She was still holding the Polaroid at arm's length, and her eyes were wet and entirely steady, and when she spoke at last it was not to Diane and it was not, in any way that could be answered, to him. It was the first true sentence she had said about her second daughter in twenty-six years, and it came out of her plainly, like a name finally pronounced correctly.
"She has Belle's face," Catherine said. "She had it first — she was born seven minutes earlier. She is the elder."
Nora Quinn walked up the front walk of the Hollis house at four o'clock in a dress she had bought for a friend's wedding two summers before, carrying nothing, her hands empty at her sides the way she carried them through the dining room at The Gannet when the trays were all delivered.
Catherine Hollis opened the door herself. There was certainly someone employed to open doors in a house of this size, but it was Catherine who stood there, in a gray dress with no ornament at all, looking less like a woman receiving a guest than like a woman keeping an appointment she had made with herself.
"You came," Catherine said.
"I said I would."
"I know what you said. People say things in my house. It has always been a house where people say things." She stepped back. "Come in. You are the only one today I am certain of."
The drawing room had been arranged. Its tall windows gave onto the street and, beyond the rooftops, the harbor. The chairs stood in a loose arc before the fireplace — a deliberate geometry, the geometry of rooms in which this family had performed itself for thirty-four years. Six chairs, Nora counted, because counting was what she did instead of trembling. A low table held a tray of tea things, untouched. And beside the fireplace, apart from the arc, sat one chair more, straight-backed, near the window — as if for someone present by obligation rather than by welcome.
Richard Hollis stood when she came in: a tall man going soft in the way of powerful men no longer watched by anyone they fear.
"Nora," he said.
"Mr. Hollis," she said.
Belle rose from the far end of the arc. Isabelle Hollis, twenty-six, Nora's sister — the word still new enough in Nora's mind that it made a small sound when it moved, like a cup set down on a saucer. She had their mother's coloring and a face Nora had seen enough, in the space of a day, to stop being startled by its nearness to her own. Belle crossed the room and did not hug her, and Nora was grateful for that restraint.
"I saved you the window end," Belle said. "Ends are easier. You can leave from an end."
"Thank you," Nora said, and sat, and found Belle had been right.
Diane Frost was already seated at the room's edge, out of the arc entirely, a notebook closed on her lap and a pen laid across it like a seal. She had chosen the edge herself. She inclined her head without rising. "Miss Quinn. For the record we are not keeping, I am glad you came."
And in the straight-backed chair by the window sat Dr. Henry Alcott.
He was eighty-four years old and looked it the way cathedrals look their age — structurally, in the beams. His hands rested on his knees: spotted, careful hands, the fingers long even in ruin. Those hands had been the first hands ever laid on her. They had lifted her and weighed her — four pounds nine ounces, the smaller twin. And she had been *first*. Seven minutes before Belle. The elder.
Alcott's eyes were on the window. He did not look at her. She understood that looking at her was the thing he had been saving, or dreading, or both, and that he would do it when it was required and not before.
Catherine took the chair at the center of the arc and looked once around it: her husband, her daughters, the old man by the window, the attorney at the edge.
"We are here because twenty-six years ago a decision was made in this family without my knowledge, and yesterday I ended the not-knowing of it. We are here to have the truth said once, in this room, in front of witnesses, by the man who can say it first-hand. After that, each of us will do what we will do, and no one in this room will ever again be able to say they did not hear it."
She said it without heat. Then she turned her head toward the window. "Henry. Begin where it begins."
The old man was quiet a moment. When Alcott spoke, his voice was dry and unhurried.