Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The stop: Officer Michael Williams's body camera activated at 9:06 p.m., three blocks from the library, four blocks from the store, on the street Marcus had walked home for eighteen years. In the footage — Marcus had watched it eleven times, until he could recite his own politeness back to it — a young man in a yellow shirt the color of a traffic signal walks with a stack of books against his chest and his employee badge swinging on its lanyard, and stops when he is told to stop, and puts his hands where they can be seen, and says Good evening, officer, in the voice his mother drilled into him before he was tall enough to see over the kitchen counter.

Nine minutes. That was the State's invisible accomplice: nine minutes in which a six-foot gunman in black was required to become a five-foot-eight librarian in yellow, shedding a hoodie, a cap, and a gun that was never found, acquiring textbooks and a badge and forty-one nights of documented routine, and arranging to be walking — not running, walking, breathing evenly, the body-cam was merciless on this point — in the opposite direction from the store, toward home.

Nine minutes, Marcus said aloud to the empty law section, on the night he finished the timeline and ruled it into columns on the legal pad. "They need me to be two people. Their whole case needs me to be two people."

He wrote the motions the way he had written his graduation speech — longhand first, then typed on the library's public computer after closing, the printer warming the pages as they came. The motion to suppress the identification ran to nineteen pages. He had built it out of the cases he had read for love before he read them for survival: Neil v. Biggers and its five factors, Manson v. Brathwaite, and Maryland's own law on show-up identifications, which disfavored them precisely because they were what this one had been — a single suspect, handcuffed, lit like a stage, flanked by uniformed officers, presented to a traumatized witness in a police cruiser with the question already shaped like an answer: Is that him? Not Do you see the man? Not Take your time. Is that him — a question with one door in it.

The motion to correct the arrest record was shorter and, in its way, sadder: a formal request that the State amend a document that described a six-foot suspect and an eighteen-year-old defendant as though they were interchangeable, that listed a height its author had never measured, copied from a broadcast about a different man. Attached: his pediatric records. His license. A photograph of a pencil mark on a door frame, which Mitchell had made him remove — "The records, Marcus. Judges eat records. They do not eat memorabilia." — and which he kept anyway, in the folder his mother had labeled.

He filed them on a Tuesday morning, walking the copies to the clerk's office himself, in the suit — the only suit, the one that fit, bought for graduation and interviews, not the wrinkled borrowed one the arraignment had dressed him in. The clerk stamped his copies with a sound like a small, decisive thunderclap. RECEIVED. He stood at the counter a moment longer than necessary, looking at the stamp, while behind him the courthouse went about its business of other people's emergencies.

You did the hard part, Mitchell said that night, reading the file-stamped copies at the kitchen table with a pencil in her hand and her reading glasses low on her nose. "Now comes the part where we find out if anybody in that building reads as carefully as you write."

Gregory Hale read carefully. That was, in the end, the thing nobody had warned Marcus about the prosecutor: that beneath the smirk he had worn at the arraignment like a second tie, beneath the forty-one felony trials and the office with the river view, there lived a man who read every page put in front of him, because he had lost a case in his second year to a footnote and had sworn a private oath over the wreckage.

He read the suppression motion standing up. His office was quiet in the way of offices at 7:40 in the morning, before the phones remembered their purpose. Rain had come in off the harbor in the night and the windows were still beaded with it, and the city below was the gray-blue of a held breath. Nineteen pages. He read the statement of facts without moving. He read the Biggers analysis with a pen in his hand, and the pen, which had begun the morning poised to annotate errors, found progressively less to do.

The show-up. Hale had known about the show-up, of course — it was in his own file, in the reports he had skimmed the week the case was assigned to him among thirty others. He had registered it the way prosecutors register defense arguments: as weather. Show-ups were challenged every week in Baltimore and upheld nearly as often; judges disliked them in the abstract and admitted them in the particular, and the particular here had seemed sound enough. A witness. A prompt identification. A suspect found nearby.

But the kid — the defendant — had not argued the show-up the way defendants argued it, in the grammar of grievance. He had argued it the way the Maryland Court of Appeals argued it. He had pulled the body-cam transcript apart by timestamps. He had juxtaposed Davis's twenty-nine seconds at the curb — I didn't get a real good look at his face — against the four-hours-later statement with an almost surgical absence of commentary, letting the two documents indict each other. He had cited the suggestiveness factors in order, applied each one to facts Hale could not dispute because they were drawn from the State's own discovery, and concluded with a paragraph Hale read twice:

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part