Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 16

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He turned off the lamp. In the dark, the library settled around him with the sound old buildings make when they are keeping their promises, and Marcus Williams locked the door behind him with the care of a man locking up his own future, and walked home through the streets he had navigated safely for eighteen years, under a sky gone clear after the rain, toward the small apartment where two letters hung level in the hallway and his mother was waiting up with the porch light on.

The courtroom had not been full for a suppression hearing in anyone's memory, and the bailiff kept saying so to no one in particular, standing at the rail with his arms folded, watching the benches fill the way a man watches weather come in off the water. Press in the back row. That was the phrase that had traveled down the courthouse steps all morning, through the metal detectors, into the marble hall where the air always smelled faintly of old paper and floor wax. Press in the back row, because somebody at a television station had gotten hold of the Harvard angle — Harvard-bound valedictorian, full scholarship, armed robbery charge — and a story like that did not stay in the legal notices. It climbed. It put on a suit. It sat down in the back row with a notebook and waited to see what kind of country this was going to turn out to be.

Marcus Williams sat at the defense table with his hands flat on either side of a legal pad, and he did not look at the back row. He had decided that the night before, sitting at the kitchen table while his mother moved around him in the particular silence she used when she was praying without words. He would not perform for the cameras. He would not perform for anyone. The law did not care who was watching, and so neither would he, and that was the discipline of it, and he held to it the way he held to everything: by deciding once and then not deciding again.

The suit was the public defender's suit no longer. Patricia Williams had taken it in at the seams over three nights, her reading glasses low on her nose, the needle going in and out under the kitchen lamp while Marcus read case law aloud from the other side of the table so that the hours would belong to both of them. The shoulders sat where shoulders were supposed to sit now. The sleeves broke at the wrist. He looked, Lauren Mitchell thought, watching him from the standby counsel chair at the far end of the table, less like a defendant and more like what he had been four months ago on the stage of Benjamin Banneker High School: a young man who had prepared.

The State versus Marcus Williams, the clerk called. "Motion to suppress identification. Court is now in session, the Honorable Judge Morrison presiding."

Morrison came through the side door with his robe already settled and his face arranged, and Marcus, who had studied that face the way he studied everything that stood between him and the rest of his life, saw the difference immediately. At the arraignment the judge had been expansive, theatrical, a man performing contempt for an audience of clerks and court officers, waving the boy away like a fly. Today there were eyes. Today there was a back row. And so today Judge Morrison was clipped and correct and careful, every syllable filed down to its legal minimum, and he addressed the courtroom with the gray courtesy of a man who has been informed that history might be taking notes.

Counsel, he said. "Mr. Hale. Mr. Williams." He said the name without ornament, and if it cost him something, the cost did not show. "We are here on the defendant's motion to suppress the out-of-court identification. The State will bear the burden. Mr. Hale, you may call your first witness — or, Mr. Williams, as the moving party, the Court will hear your opening first, if you wish to make one."

I do, Your Honor, Marcus said, and stood.

There is a sound a courtroom makes when a defendant representing himself rises to speak, and Marcus had heard it at the arraignment: a small, pitying weather system of shifted weight and cleared throats, the sound of people preparing to be embarrassed on someone else's behalf. He heard the beginning of it now. He had planned for it the way he planned for everything, and what he did was nothing at all. He waited. He let the silence do the first part of the work, the way his mother had taught him to let a room settle before you said the thing that mattered, and he looked up at the bench, and only at the bench, and began.

Your Honor, on the night of August twenty-second, at approximately nine-fifteen in the evening, I was standing on a sidewalk in handcuffs, between two uniformed officers, in the beam of a police spotlight, when a patrol car carrying Mr. Jimmy Davis slowed in front of me. Mr. Davis had been robbed at gunpoint forty minutes before. He was, understandably, terrified. The officer driving him did not ask him to look at a group of men. He did not ask him to look at photographs. He drove him past one man — one — a man already in custody, already lit like a stage, already framed by two officers as the answer to the question — and he said, and I quote from the officer's own report, 'We got him. Is this the man?'

He let that sit.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part