Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 17

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Under Neil versus Biggers, and under Manson versus Brathwaite, this Court must ask two questions. Was the procedure impermissibly suggestive? And if it was, was the identification nevertheless reliable under the totality of the circumstances? The defense will show that a single-person show-up, conducted curbside, at night, with the suspect handcuffed and spotlit, prefaced by an officer announcing 'we got him,' is suggestiveness in its purest distilled form — it is not a procedure for finding the truth, Your Honor, it is a procedure for confirming a conclusion. And the defense will further show that every one of the Biggers reliability factors — the witness's opportunity to view, his degree of attention, the accuracy of his prior description, his level of certainty, and the time between the crime and the confrontation — every one of them fails the State in this case. The description Mr. Davis gave at his store was of a man six feet tall. I am five feet eight inches. The man wore dark clothing and a cap. I was wearing a yellow library shirt with my employer's name on the chest, carrying textbooks, with my employee identification badge clipped to my belt.

He turned one page of the legal pad over. His hand did not shake. He had noticed, in the weeks of preparation, that his hands shook only when he was idle, and so he had simply stopped being idle.

The State will ask this Court to let a jury hear that Jimmy Davis identified me. But what Mr. Davis identified, Your Honor, was not a memory. It was a suggestion, delivered in a spotlight, by men he trusted, at the worst hour of his life. The defense asks the Court to suppress the identification and all testimony arising from it.

He sat down.

The room did something then that Marcus would remember long after he had forgotten the wording of his own argument. It did not applaud — courtrooms do not applaud — and it did not gasp. It went still in a way that was different from silence, the way a lake is different from a photograph of a lake. In the back row, a reporter lowered her pen. In the gallery, Patricia Williams sat with the Harvard acceptance letter folded in her purse — she carried it everywhere now, the way other women carried photographs — and her hands, which had trembled at the arraignment, were perfectly steady in her lap, because her son had just spoken in a courtroom the way she had always known he could, and there was nothing left in her that needed to be afraid of the sound of his voice.

At the prosecution table, Gregory Hale was writing something on his own pad, writing it slowly, and Lauren Mitchell, who had read Marcus's motion three times and annotated it in two colors of ink and found almost nothing to correct, watched the judge instead. Morrison was looking down at the motion in front of him. He had read it before — of course he had read it — but there is a difference between reading words on a page and hearing them built, brick by brick, in the air of your own courtroom by an eighteen-year-old you laughed at. Marcus had watched him at the arraignment reach for his gavel like a man reaching for the end of a conversation. Nobody was reaching for anything now.

Mr. Hale, Morrison said at last, and his voice was even, and if there was anything underneath the evenness, he kept it there. "Call your witness."

Hale stood. "The State calls Officer Michael Williams."

The side door opened, and the officer came in in his dress uniform, and he took the oath with his hand raised, and the hearing — the real one, the one that would decide what a jury would ever be allowed to hear — began.

Officer Michael Williams had been on the stand for the State for twenty minutes, and Hale had walked him through it the way you walk a man through his own house: the call, the description broadcast, the drive to the neighborhood, the young man on the sidewalk three blocks from Jimmy Davis's store, the stop. It had all sounded clean. It had all sounded like the report. Marcus had taken notes in a hand so steady and so small that Mitchell, glancing sideways, thought of monks, of copyists, of people who believed that the written word was a form of armor. Now Hale sat down, and Morrison nodded toward the defense table, and said, "Your witness, Mr. Williams," and the shared surname hung in the air for half a second the way it had hung there since the night of the arrest, a coincidence nobody in the room had stopped finding strange.

Marcus stood with his pad. "Officer Williams, good morning."

Morning.

You testified that at approximately nine p.m. on August twenty-second, you stopped me on the sidewalk. What was the basis for the stop?

The broadcast description, the officer said. "Armed robbery at Davis's store, suspect a young Black male, approximately six feet, dark clothing, baseball cap. You were in the area, on foot, near the scene."

I was three blocks from the scene.

Three blocks is near.

It is, Marcus said. "Let's talk about the description. Six feet tall. Officer, how tall am I?"

The officer looked at him. It was the first time, Marcus realized, that the man had ever actually looked at him — not at a suspect, not at a silhouette in a spotlight, but at the person, seated now at eye level in a fitted suit. "I couldn't say exactly."

Would it surprise you to learn that my booking record lists me at five feet eight inches?

No.

And your arrest report — the one you wrote that night — lists the suspect's height as six feet. Is that right?

That's what the broadcast said.

But the report isn't the broadcast, Officer. The report is your account of the man you arrested. You wrote six feet in the box marked 'height' on the arrest report of a man who is five foot eight. Yes or no?

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part