Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Hale set the receiver down, the way a man handles something that has already broken.

His second chair that term was a young prosecutor named Daniel Osei, twenty-six, eighteen months out of law school, who still believed the job was the one described at his swearing-in. Hale called him back into the office from the hallway, and told him, without the weather, what the decision was.

Osei was quiet a moment. "Sir. The identification's suppressed. Davis can't ID him. The description— the description's a horoscope, sir. And Boyd—"

Boyd is the defense's witness problem and gift, and they'll make the most of both.

Then what do we *have*?

We have a young man three blocks from a robbery, at the time of the robbery, who ran— Hale stopped. "Who did not run. Who stood on the sidewalk with his hands visible and his library badge around his neck and answered an officer's questions, which the officer then described, in a report I have read too many times, as evasive." He looked at the three files. "That is what we have. Presence. A jury instruction on mere presence that the defense will request and the court will give — and twelve citizens who may or may not obey it."

And we try it anyway, Osei said. It was not quite a question.

We try it anyway, Hale said, "because the office has decided that its reputation is a fact in evidence." He stood, and put the laundromat frame back in its sleeve with a care that surprised his own hands. "Listen to me, Daniel, because this is the only useful thing I will teach you this year. We try it *straight*. No sandbagging the defense on discovery — Mitchell gets everything, every time; she's earned that and so has he. No theatrics with the jury about the neighborhood. No leaning on Davis. We put on what we have, we argue it inside the rules, and if the rules say it's not enough, then it is not enough, and I will stand up at the end of it and say the State accepts the verdict, and I will mean it. If this office is going to be wrong, it will be wrong in daylight, inside the lines, with its shoes shined. Do you understand me?"

Yes sir, Osei said, and then, after a moment, in the voice of a man filing something away for the rest of his life: "And God help us."

Then we try it, Hale said. "And God help us, we try it straight."

Across the city, in a second-floor apartment in East Baltimore where the streetlight made a familiar amber rectangle on the ceiling, Marcus Williams laid out his morning on the bed his mother had made with hospital corners.

The suit first: the same suit, altered now — Patricia had taken it in at the waist and let the sleeves to their true length across three evenings, and it no longer looked borrowed. It looked like his. Beside it, his shirt, pressed. His tie. The notebook, closed, with the opening statement inside it in the hand that did not shake. His copy of the suppression order, folded once, the way other men carry psalms. And last, the photograph: his father, young, standing in front of a church that no longer stood, squinting into a sun that no longer shone, one hand raised against the light. Marcus had taken it from the frame on the wall for the first time in eleven years. He would carry it in the inside pocket, over his heart, where the bailiffs' hands would not go.

Patricia stood in the doorway with her arms folded, not entering, because she understood rooms that a man has to arrange for himself.

You sleep tonight, she said. "Whatever else. You hear me? A rested mind, Marcus. That's an order from a medical professional."

Yes ma'am, he said. "I'll sleep."

You'll try, she corrected, and the corner of her mouth moved. "It's enough. Trying is most of what anybody does in that building." She looked at the bed, at the suit, at the photograph, and something in her face settled, the way a house settles into its foundation. "He'd be beside himself, your daddy. Not scared. *Beside* himself. He always said you'd be the one to take the family's name somewhere it had to be *announced*." She nodded once, at the bed, at all of it. "Well. Tomorrow they announce it. One way or the other, in that room, out loud — they're going to say your name right, or they're going to have to work very hard not to. Sleep, baby."

She went out. The apartment quieted. Marcus set the alarm for five, though he knew he would be awake before it, and turned out the light, and lay in the amber dark listening to the building breathe, and did not rehearse, and did not pray in words. He thought about a laundromat camera, patient and unblinking, that had simply kept looking after everyone else had decided what they saw. He thought: *tomorrow, I keep looking too.*

He slept.

The jury panel came in at nine in the morning, forty-one men and women filing into the box and the first two rows of the gallery with the shuffling, resentful patience of people who had been summoned out of their lives by a card in the mail. They carried the low-grade suspicion, common to every courthouse in America, that they were about to be made fools of by professionals. Marcus Williams stood when they entered. Nobody had told him to stand. Lauren Mitchell, seated beside him at the defense table in her role as standby counsel, watched him do it and understood before he could have explained it: he was not performing courtesy. He was counting. He was looking at the forty-one faces the way he had once looked at a chess problem or a statute, searching for the structure inside the noise.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part