Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The Committee on Admissions had followed his case, the letter said, with concern and with admiration for his record. His place in the incoming class remained his. His scholarship remained intact. Harvard did not abandon its students at the first sound of thunder, and it did not intend to abandon him. However — and the letter's whole weight shifted, the way a body shifts its weight before a blow — enrollment was contingent upon the resolution of pending legal matters. A student under felony indictment could not matriculate. Should the matter resolve in his favor, his place would be held through the following fall, with his scholarship preserved in full. Should it not — the letter did not finish that sentence. It did something more Harvard than finishing it. It expressed confidence in the process.

Patricia read it standing at the kitchen counter, twice. Then she got up — Marcus watched her, saying nothing — and went to the small hallway where the acceptance letter hung in its frame, and she took a second frame down from the shelf where it had waited since his graduation, empty, bought for a photograph that had never been printed. She put the contingency letter in it. She hung it beside the first. Two cream-colored rectangles, side by side, level as pictures in a gallery.

Ma, Marcus said. "What are you doing?"

I'm hanging them together, Patricia said, "so they can keep each other honest."

She stepped back and looked at the pair of them — the promise and the condition, the door and the lock on the door — with her arms crossed and her chin up, in the posture of a woman who had decided that the truth, hung straight and in the light, was less frightening than the truth in a drawer.

The first one says who you are, she said. "The second one says what the world is. You're going to need to remember both of those things at the same time for the rest of your life, baby. Might as well practice in the hallway."

That night the library kept him after closing one more time, the way it had kept him since he was fourteen — a conspiracy of librarians so gentle it had never once been spoken aloud. Mrs. Abernathy at the front desk signed the volunteer log with a flourish and went home. Mr. Osei, who ran the law section and had ordered the first constitutional law textbook into Marcus's hands three summers ago with the words try this one, it's dry as dust and it'll change your life, set the brass lamp on the long oak table and said, "Lock up when you're done, Marcus. You know how," and left him in the green-shaded pool of light with the tall windows going black and the stacks standing around him like a jury that had already decided to be fair.

He read the rules of evidence the way he had read everything that mattered — pencil in hand, notebook open, his whole body leaned into the page. Hearsay and its exceptions. Authentication. The rule against character evidence and the doors it opened. He read about impeachment, about the ways a witness's certainty could be shown to a jury as the manufactured thing it sometimes was, and he thought about Jimmy Davis saying don't look at me in a shaking voice at a curb, and saying clear as day four hours later in a quiet room, and he understood that his case would not be won by the timeline or the tape or the nine impossible minutes, not finally. It would be won or lost in the space between those two sentences — the space where a frightened man's memory had been remodeled by the people who were supposed to protect it.

His pencil stopped, halfway down a page, on the standard for suppression hearings. The burden. The factors. The choreography of Tuesday.

Tuesday. The suppression hearing, nine-thirty, Judge Morrison's courtroom, the same room where a man in a robe had laughed and called him a street thug playing Perry Mason, where his mother had sat frozen with the acceptance letter trembling in her hands like something alive. On Tuesday he would stand at the defense table — not in handcuffs, not in a borrowed suit two sizes too big, but on his feet as his own counsel — and he would ask that court, on the record, under the rules he was reading by lamplight, to throw out the only identification the State had. And Morrison would have to listen. That was the terrible, beautiful machinery of it. Morrison would have to listen, and rule, and be reviewed on the ruling, and the court reporter would type every word, including the words of the boy he had already sentenced in a sentence: You're going to prison, boy. The only question is for how long.

Marcus marked the page with a strip of notebook paper. Then he marked it again, more carefully, the way you mark a place you intend to come back to and stand on.

He closed the book. He sat a while in the lamplight with his hands flat on the oak table, feeling the grain of it, the years of readers in its polish, and he thought about his father, whom he could remember only as a laugh from another room and a pair of hands lifting him toward a ceiling fan's pull-chain, and about his mother hanging two letters in a hallway so they could keep each other honest, and about a judge who had looked at him and seen a thug, and a store owner who had looked at a photograph of fear and seen his face.

All right, Marcus said quietly, to the stacks, to the lamp, to the fourteen-year-old ghost of himself shelving books in the next aisle, who had read Gideon by this same light and never imagined the petitioner would be him. "Tuesday, then."

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part