Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 31

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Mr. Williams, Judge Morrison said, from the bench, in the voice he used for weather reports and sentences, "you may inquire of the panel."

It was the first time the judge had addressed him by his name in open court since the morning, four months gone, when he had laughed at him. Marcus gathered his notes — three pages, written in pencil the night before at his mother's kitchen table, in the small hours when the apartment building was quiet and the acceptance letter sat propped against the sugar jar like a member of the family — and he walked to the lectern.

He did not ask the questions the room expected. He did not ask about television crime shows or newspaper habits or whether anyone had a cousin on the force. He asked, of the first row, a question so simple that the court reporter looked up from her machine.

Have you ever been judged, Marcus said, "by someone who decided what you were before you opened your mouth?"

The silence that followed was not embarrassment. It was recognition, moving through the panel like weather through wheat. A woman in the third seat of the first row, a school bus driver with her hair in a gray braid, laughed once — not at him, at the memory of something. "Judge at my custody hearing," she said. "Nineteen ninety-eight. He had his mind made up before my lawyer sat down." Marcus nodded, and thanked her, and asked the room whether anyone would hold it against a man for wanting the people who judged him to have felt that particular wind at least once in their lives.

Hale rose twice to object, and twice Morrison overruled him, and something in the manner of the overruling — unhurried, almost courteous — told the gallery that the judge had decided, somewhere in the months between the laugh and this morning, to let the boy run his own race inside the lines. Marcus used his strikes like a man spending money he had saved for years. He struck a retired insurance adjuster who said, twice, that where there was smoke there was usually fire. He struck a young man who kept calling him "the defendant" with a relish that belonged in a locker room. He kept the bus driver. He kept a retired machinist from Dundalk who said he had been arrested once, at nineteen, for a burglary committed by a cousin with his same first name, and who had waited eleven hours in a cell for the mistake to be believed by anyone with a key. He kept a nurse — he could not help it, he kept the nurse — who worked the night shift and said she knew what it was to be looked at and summarized.

You understand, Hale said to the nurse, on his own inquiry, "that sympathy is not evidence."

I understand, she said, "that evidence is evidence. That's why I'm still sitting here."

By eleven the jury was seated: twelve people and two alternates, seven women and five men, Black and white and one Salvadoran grandmother who had raised six children two miles from Jimmy Davis's store and who told the court, in accented and absolute English, that a description was a net and nets caught whatever swam, not whatever was guilty. Marcus returned to the defense table with his hands trembling so finely that he had to press them flat against the wood to still them, and Lauren, without looking at him, slid her legal pad an inch toward his side of the table, a small and deliberate kindness, an anchor disguised as stationery.

Then the openings.

Hale went first, because the state always goes first, and he did what a careful man does with a case he no longer believes in: he made it small. He spoke of presence. He spoke of proximity. He spoke of a young man found three blocks from a robbed store on the night of the robbery, and of the jury's duty to weigh the whole picture, and he said the words "the whole picture" four times, as if repetition could give them weight. He did not mention a weapon, because there was none. He did not mention money, because there was none. He did not mention an identification, because the one identification the state had ever possessed had been taken from it by the law itself, in this room, by the boy now sitting at the defense table in a suit that finally fit him. Hale sat down after eleven minutes. It was a competent opening. It was a short opening. It had the sound, unmistakable to everyone in the room who had ever heard a man read a eulogy for a stranger, of an apology being delivered in advance, in the wrong tense.

Mr. Williams, said Judge Morrison.

Marcus stood. He had written his opening statement out in full, the way he had written his valedictory address, and then, the night before, he had done to it what he had done to the speech: he had memorized it, and then he had put the paper away, because a thing read is a thing reported and a thing spoken from the chest is a thing witnessed. He walked to the rail of the jury box and he did not raise his voice at any point in the next twenty-two minutes.

Members of the jury, he said, "I am not going to ask you to like me. I am going to ask you to do something harder. I am going to ask you to watch the state's case the way you would watch a building being built, and to notice what is holding it up."

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part