We'll take fifteen minutes, he said. "Then the State will call Mr. Davis."
Jimmy Davis did not look like the State's centerpiece. He looked like a man who had been carrying something heavy up a long flight of stairs and had been told, at the top, that he would have to describe the weight under oath. He was fifty-nine years old and he had owned the corner store for thirty-one of them, and he wore his good suit — the one for church and funerals, Marcus thought, and then thought, with a small interior flinch at his own clarity, that for Davis this probably counted as both. His hands worried the arms of the witness chair. When Hale led him through the robbery he spoke in the flat, exhausted cadence of a man who has told the story to police, to insurance people, to his wife, to the ceiling at three in the morning, and has found that telling it does not make it any lighter.
A man had come in at eight-forty, near closing. A gun. A voice saying don't make it hard. The register. Forty seconds — Davis said forty seconds and then, honest even in this, corrected himself: "Maybe it wasn't forty. It felt like forty. It could have been twenty. When a man's pointing a gun at you, time does a thing."
Hale was gentle with him, and Marcus, listening, understood that the gentleness was also strategy and did not hold it against either of them. Hale was doing what Marcus himself would have done: he was letting the jury-that-wasn't-there, the judge, the press row, see that Jimmy Davis was not a villain in this. He was a frightened man who had been robbed at gunpoint in the store he had built out of nothing, who had wanted to help, who had been driven past a spotlight by men with badges and asked a question in the worst hour of his life.
Hale asked him about the store, too — not the robbery, the store. Thirty-one years. A lease signed when the neighborhood was different, a son who had worked the counter through high school and now drove a truck in Ohio, a wife who did the books on Sundays. Davis answered those questions with the first ease he had shown all morning, and Marcus understood that too: Hale was building a man, not a witness, because men are believed in ways witnesses are not. It was good lawyering. Marcus filed it away the way he filed everything — not with resentment, but with respect, and with the quiet knowledge that when his turn came he would have to build the same man back into the truth, and that the truth, in this case, was on the man's own side, if Marcus could only lead him to the place where he was allowed to say it. The State's last question was the important one.
Mr. Davis, when you saw the defendant that night, did you identify him as the man who robbed you?
I said he was the one, Davis said. "Yes. I did."
No further questions.
Morrison looked at the defense table. "Mr. Williams."
Marcus rose, and everything he did next he did at half the volume of the room's expectation. He had rehearsed this cross-examination in the library after closing, in the law section, with the chairs for company, and what he had decided — decided the way he decided everything, once, and then not again — was that Jimmy Davis was not his enemy and would not be treated as one. The enemy was a procedure. The enemy was a spotlight and a sentence that began we got him. Davis was a man who had had a gun in his face, and Marcus's mother had raised him in a neighborhood where you did not confuse the two.
Mr. Davis, I'm sorry for what happened to you that night, he said. "I want to ask you about it carefully, and if I ask anything unclearly, please tell me."
Davis blinked. "All right."
The man who robbed you — during those forty seconds, or twenty — where was your attention, mostly?
On the gun, Davis said, immediately. "Mostly on the gun."
Why the gun?
Because— Davis's hands tightened. "Because that's the part that can kill you. A face can't kill you. I remember the gun better than I remember my own mother's face, son. I dream about the gun."
You dream about the gun, Marcus said. "Mr. Davis, at the store, that night, when the police asked you to describe the man, you told them six feet tall, dark clothes, a cap pulled low. Do you remember giving that description?"
I remember trying.
The cap was pulled low. How much of his face could you see below the cap?
Davis was quiet a moment. "Not — not a lot. The light in my store, the fluorescents, one of them's been flickering since spring. He kept his head down some."
And his height — six feet. How did you judge that?
He seemed tall. Standing over the counter, he seemed — the counter comes up to here on me— He gestured. "He seemed tall over it."
You'd never measured him against anything.
No.
Now the identification. You were put in a patrol car. It was raining that night, wasn't it?
Some. On and off.
The window beside you — was it clear?
Davis frowned, reaching for it honestly. "It had rain on it. Flecks. The driver — he ran the wiper once, I think. Maybe once."
And as the car approached where I was standing, there was a spotlight.