Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 33

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Morning.

We are not related, are we, sir?

A flicker, at the corner of the officer's mouth. "No. We're not."

I only ask because the name has caused confusion in the papers, and I want the record clean. You stopped me at about five minutes past nine. Correct?

Approximately, yes.

Where exactly?

On Madeira Street. Near the corner of — near the alley that runs behind the laundromat.

Three blocks from Mr. Davis's store.

Roughly three blocks, yes.

Now. The description you were given, over the radio, before you ever saw me. Let's get it exact. Young Black male. Approximately six feet tall. Dark clothing. A baseball cap. Is that right?

That was the broadcast, yes.

Officer, how tall are you?

Six-one.

And you and I have stood in the same room several times now. In your judgment, as a trained observer — how tall am I?

The officer looked at him for a moment, and something in the room went very still, because everyone present understood that the man on the stand had arrived at the fork in the road that Marcus had spent four months building, stone by stone, out of the officer's own reports. "You're about five-eight," Officer Williams said. "Five-nine in shoes."

Four inches shorter than the man in the description.

The description said approximately.

It did. Let's talk about approximately. If a witness told you a car was approximately a truck, would you stop every sedan on the street?

Objection, Hale said, without heat. "Argumentative."

Sustained, said Morrison. "Mr. Williams."

Withdrawn, Marcus said. "Officer — the clothing. The broadcast said dark clothing. What was I wearing when you stopped me?"

A yellow shirt. A bright yellow shirt.

It said LIBRARY VOLUNTEER across the back, didn't it? In reflective letters.

It did.

And what was I carrying?

Books. A stack of books, and a — a bag.

Textbooks. Constitutional law, if it matters, which it doesn't, except that it tells the jury what I was doing that evening. And my library identification badge, on a lanyard, with my photograph and my name. You saw the badge.

I saw it, yes.

Did you find a weapon on me, Officer?

No.

Did you find money — a roll of bills, a cash drawer, anything like the proceeds of a robbery?

No.

Did you find a baseball cap on me, or near me, or anywhere along the street where you stopped me?

No.

Did you find dark clothing of any kind in my possession?

No.

Did you, at any point that night, go back and check the camera mounted over the laundromat door on Madeira Street — the camera that points directly at the spot where you stopped me, and at the alley behind it?

The officer's jaw worked once. "I did not."

Did any officer, to your knowledge, ever request the film from that camera?

Not that I know of.

That camera's film was later obtained by the defense, Officer. It was obtained by my mother, in fact, who walked into that laundromat with a cake she had baked and asked politely, which is a method I recommend to the Baltimore Police Department. A sound went through the gallery, half laugh, half something else, and Morrison let it live and die on its own. "We will come to what that film shows with another witness. For now, I want to ask you about the moment itself. When you stopped me, did I run?"

No.

Did I reach for anything, or throw anything away, or change direction?

No. You stopped when I called out. You put your hands up before I asked. You said —  The officer stopped.

What did I say, Officer?

You said, 'Good evening, officer.'

'Good evening, officer.' And then I told you my name, and where I worked, and that I had just finished my shift, and I asked if something had happened. Is that right?

That's right.

And you detained me anyway.

I detained you because you matched the description in the general area.

Marcus let the sentence sit in the air between them, unhurried, the way his grandfather — a man he had never met, who had died before Marcus was born and who survived in the family as a standard of conduct — was said to let a pot come to a boil. "Officer Williams, I want to be careful here, and fair. In your report, written that night, you wrote that I was detained because I, quote, matched the description and was in the vicinity. You've testified to the height. Four inches off. The clothing. Bright yellow against dark. The cap. Absent. So I want to ask you the question this whole case stands on, and I want you to answer it the way you'd answer it at your own kitchen table. Apart from being a young Black man, three blocks from a crime, on a street he had walked home on for four years — what did I match?"

The officer looked at Hale. Hale was studying the grain of the state's table with the concentration of a man reading scripture in a language he was still learning. The officer looked at the jury. The bus driver was watching him with an expression entirely free of cruelty and entirely free of mercy.

He matched the general description, Officer Williams said at last. "In the general area. That was the whole of it."

That was the whole of it, Marcus repeated, quietly, not as a taunt but as a transcription, for the record and for the room. "No further questions, Your Honor."

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part