He built it in the air for them, piece by piece, the way his mother had taught him to build an argument at a kitchen table in East Baltimore, one true thing at a time. A store was robbed by a tall man. Not a man of average height, not a young man in bright colors — a tall man, six feet or better, in dark clothes and a cap, who walked with a limp that the store's owner had seen and sworn to. Three blocks away, at almost the same hour, a police officer stopped a young man of five feet eight, wearing a yellow library shirt bright enough to be seen from the moon, carrying textbooks and a library badge with his name printed on it in letters an inch high. No gun was found on him, because he had never held one. No money was found on him, because he had taken none. No cap was found on him, because he did not own one. And the camera — he paused there, and let the pause do the work of a paragraph — "the camera across the street from that store, the one that watched the door all night, the police never asked for its film. Not that night. Not that week. You will hear why. You will hear it from them."
He told them about the library, and a time clock, and a woman named Evelyn Brooks who kept records the way other people kept photographs. He told them that at the minute the tall man was limping out of Jimmy Davis's store with a gun in his hand, Marcus Williams was on camera, in a yellow shirt, putting books on a shelf, in a building full of witnesses.
They will not be able to put me in that store, he said, "because I was never in that store. They will not be able to put a gun in my hand, because my hands were on books. The state has had four months, members of the jury. Four months, and detectives, and a laboratory, and the whole machinery of the city of Baltimore. And what they have brought you is a boy in a yellow shirt, standing near a crime he did not commit, in a neighborhood he has lived in for eighteen years — as if living somewhere were a kind of evidence. As if being findable were the same as being guilty."
He turned then, slightly, not toward the bench, not toward the gallery where his mother sat with her hands folded around the letter she had brought again, folded and refolded until its edges were soft as cloth, but toward the whole room, toward the record.
At the end of this trial, Marcus said, "I am going to ask you for the only verdict the evidence can carry. Not because of who I am. Because of what is not there. A case is a building. Watch what it stands on. Thank you."
He sat down. The courtroom did not move. It was not the silence of politeness, and it was not the silence of shock; it was the particular, dense silence of a room full of people who have just heard a thing said exactly as well as it can be said and who are, all of them at once, revising an opinion they had carried in with their coffee. In the jury box the bus driver was looking at him the way people look at weather clearing. In the gallery Patricia Williams had both hands pressed flat over her mouth, and her shoulders were shaking, and she made no sound at all. On the bench, Judge Morrison sat with his gavel resting in his right hand, raised perhaps an inch above the sounding block, where it had been when Marcus began to speak — and it stayed there, unmoving, for a count of five, of ten, while the judge looked at the young man at the defense table with an expression that no one in that courtroom, in thirty years of watching that face, had ever seen on it. Then, quietly, almost gently, he set the gavel down without striking it, and called the state's first witness.
Officer Michael Williams took the stand in his dress uniform, with his cap under his arm and his thirty years arranged on his shoulders like epaulettes, and he swore the oath in the voice of a man who had sworn it four hundred times and expected to be believed by reflex. Hale led him through it gently, the way you lead a horse you suspect is lame. The call had come in at 8:41 p.m. A robbery at the Davis store on Monument Street. A description broadcast: young Black male, approximately six feet, dark clothing, baseball cap, last seen on foot heading west. At approximately 9:05, on a side street three blocks from the store, Officer Williams had observed the defendant and detained him. The defendant had been cooperative. The defendant had been transported. The defendant had been identified — and here Hale's voice changed, almost imperceptibly, the way a man's voice changes stepping over a crack in ice — the identification procedure, Your Honor, having been the subject of a prior ruling, the state would move on.
Move on, said Judge Morrison, and the officer moved on, and the direct examination ended four minutes later with the whole of it hanging in the air like a coat on a hook too small for it.
Marcus stood for the cross-examination with his pencil behind his ear, the way he had done his homework at the library for four summers, and the gallery — which had filled, that morning, with law students and two newspaper reporters and a delegation of quiet women from Patricia Williams's church — leaned forward as one body.
Officer Williams, Marcus said, "good morning."