Lord, yes. It was bright. It was in my eyes too, some of it, off the wet street.
You were looking at a man lit by that spotlight, through a rain-flecked window, at night. And before you said anything, Mr. Davis — I want to ask you about the officer's words. What did Officer Brennan say to you as the car slowed down?
Davis's gaze moved, involuntarily, toward Hale, and then away, and Marcus kept his own face mild and waited, because the waiting was the question too. "He said—" Davis stopped. "He said, 'We got him. Is this the man?'"
'We got him.' Not 'do you see anyone you recognize.' Not 'take your time.' 'We got him.'
That's what he said.
Mr. Davis, when you answered, what exactly did you say?
I said — I said it looked like him.
There it was. Marcus felt it go through the room the way weather goes through a field, not a sound exactly, a change in pressure. He did not step on it. He did not look at the press row. He kept his eyes on the witness, and his voice, when he spoke again, was the gentlest it had been all day, because this was the part that mattered and cruelty would have cheapened it and because the man in the chair was telling the truth at last and the truth deserved a soft landing.
You said it looked like him. Did you ever say you were sure?
No. Davis shook his head slowly, and something in his face — some knot that had been tied since August — loosened visibly. "I never said I was sure. I said it looked like him, and everybody after that said it like I'd sworn on it. The officer wrote 'positive identification.' I never used that word. I don't — I couldn't swear on it. A man had a gun in my face and I looked at the gun. Then they showed me a boy in a light and told me they'd got him, and I said it looked like him. That's all I ever said."
No further questions, Your Honor.
Marcus sat down. His mother was crying in the gallery without sound, the way she cried in church, upright, with her face lifted. Hale rose for redirect and got as far as "Mr. Davis, you did your best that night, didn't you—" before he seemed to hear the question the way the room heard it, and he said, "Nothing further," and sat down, and Jimmy Davis stepped down from the stand and walked the length of the courtroom past the defense table, and at the defense table he paused — just a fraction, just long enough for Marcus to see that the man wanted to say something and could not find the shape of it — and then he went on, out the door, into the hall, carrying his forty seconds with him.
The ruling came the following morning, and it came in writing before it came in words, because Morrison — Morrison who had laughed — had apparently decided that whatever he was going to be in this case from now on, he was going to be it on paper, where it could be checked.
The Court, he read, in the clipped, correct voice that had replaced the theatrical one, "having considered the testimony and the totality of the circumstances under Neil v. Biggers and its progeny, finds that the show-up identification procedure employed on the night of August twenty-second was impermissibly suggestive. A single suspect, handcuffed, illuminated by spotlight, presented to a traumatized witness with the prefatory assurance that police had, quote, got him, carries a corrupting effect that the subsequent reliability inquiry cannot cure — particularly where, as here, the witness's own testimony establishes that his attention during the offense was fixed upon the weapon, that his initial description conflicts materially with the defendant's actual appearance, and that his stated certainty at the confrontation was, by his own account, equivocal."
He turned a page. Patricia Williams's hand found the edge of the bench in front of her and held it.
The identification of the defendant by Mr. James Davis, and all testimony concerning it, is hereby suppressed and shall not be presented at trial.
The press row was already moving. Marcus sat very still. He had won motions before — in the abstract, in the library, in the country of his own preparation — but this was the first time a thing he had built out of reading and grief and stubbornness had been picked up by the machinery of the state and pronounced sound, and he discovered that victory, in a courtroom, did not feel like triumph. It felt like a room getting its air back.
The defendant's motion to dismiss, Morrison continued, "is denied. The State retains circumstantial evidence — the defendant's presence in the vicinity, the timeline — which, however thin the Court may privately find it, presents a question for a jury. Trial is set five weeks from today. Mr. Hale, the State will turn over any outstanding discovery within ten days. Mr. Williams — " The judge looked at him directly, and something crossed his face that was not warmth and was not contempt either, but the exhausted respect of a man who has been out-argued in his own house and knows the transcript knows it. "The Court advises you, again, to reconsider representation by counsel."
Thank you, Your Honor, Marcus said. "I'll consider it again."