In the second row of the jury box, a woman Marcus had not kept deliberately and could not now have named — a payroll clerk from Essex, fiftyish, with reading glasses on a beaded chain — closed the small notebook in which she had been taking careful notes since the first witness was sworn. She closed it slowly, and set her pen across the cover, and folded her hands on top of both, in the posture of a person who has finished a task and is waiting, now, only for the formalities to catch up with the fact. She did not open it again for the rest of the trial.
Jimmy Davis came to the stand the way a man comes to a confessional he has not chosen, in a suit jacket over a clean shirt, with his store keys making a small, bright sound in his pocket every time he moved. He was sixty-one years old and he had owned the corner store on Monument Street for twenty-eight of those years, and he had buried a wife and raised a daughter and extended credit, in a battered spiral notebook behind the counter, to half the families on his block, including, in lean years, the family of the young man now sitting at the defense table. He raised his right hand and swore to tell the truth, and his voice, when he gave his name, had the steadiness of a man who has decided in advance exactly how much of himself he is willing to lose in a room.
Hale took him through the robbery with the tenderness of a man defusing something. It had lasted, by the store clock and by Davis's own lifelong sense of time, about forty seconds. A man had come through the door at closing, tall — Davis said the word the way a man reads a measurement off a doorframe he has passed ten thousand times — "he filled the door, that's what I remember first, he filled the door" — with a hood up over a cap, and a gun in his hand, and he had moved wrong, Davis said, he had moved like one leg was arguing with the other, a hitch, a limp he'd had maybe all his life or maybe from some injury, and he had said the things men say with guns in stores, and Davis had given him the drawer money and the cigarettes he'd demanded, and he had gone, out into the dark, limping west.
What Davis did not say, because Hale had not asked it and because some things a man keeps for the small hours, was how the forty seconds had rearranged the furniture of his life. The bell over his own door — a bell he had hung himself in 1997, a bell his late wife had picked out of a catalogue — had rung wrong ever since, rung like an alarm instead of a welcome. He had taken to standing where he could see the door and the register at once. He had stopped letting neighborhood boys run tabs in the evenings, and hated himself for stopping, and the spiral notebook of credit behind the counter had a gap in it now, a month of pages with nothing written, which shamed him more than the empty drawer ever had. He told the jury the facts. The facts were the part he could carry into a room like this one. The rest he carried everywhere else.
Mr. Davis, Hale said, "can you identify the man who robbed your store?"
And there it was — the question the whole trial had been arranged around, the question that the law, in this very room, weeks earlier, had already answered by forbidding the answer Davis had once given in the back of a police car under a spotlight's glare. Davis looked at the judge. Morrison, with a care that was almost gentle, addressed the witness directly. "Mr. Davis, you may describe the man who robbed you. You may not testify to any identification made outside this courtroom. Do you understand?"
I understand, Your Honor. Davis turned his eyes to the room, and they passed over the defense table the way weather passes over a field, without stopping. "I can describe him. That's all I can do. He was tall. He was hooded. His face — most of what I saw was the gun, and a man who tells you he was looking at the face is a man who's never had a gun pointed at him in his own store. I saw the gun and I saw the door filled up and I heard his voice, older than — he was a grown man. Not a boy. That's what I know."
Hale sat down with the air of a man setting down a glass he has carried a long way without spilling, and Marcus rose, and buttoned his jacket, and what happened next took, by the court reporter's later count, four questions.
Mr. Davis, thank you for coming. I know this isn't easy, and I won't keep you long. The man who robbed your store — how tall was he?
Tall, Davis said. "Six foot. Over. He filled the door and my door is a tall door."
I am five feet eight, Mr. Davis. You've known me since I was eleven years old, coming in for my mother's groceries. In all those years, have I ever filled a door?
Something moved in Davis's face then that was not quite a smile and was not grief either, though it had elements of both. "No, Marcus. You have not."
The man who robbed you — you said he limped. Walked like one leg was arguing with the other. Have you ever seen me limp, Mr. Davis? In seven years of watching me come and go in your store?
No. Never.
He was hooded, you said, and capped, and his face was covered by both. I was stopped three blocks away in a yellow shirt with my name on a badge and my face bare to the streetlights. Mr. Davis, I am going to ask you the only other question I have, and I want you to take your time. Sitting here today, under oath — can you swear to this jury that the man who robbed your store is the man sitting at that table?