A pause. "The report carried the description over."
Carried it over, Marcus repeated, without any music in it at all, just the words set down flat like stones. "Let's talk about the clothing. The broadcast said dark clothing and a baseball cap. What was I wearing when you stopped me?"
A yellow shirt.
A yellow shirt. Bright yellow. With what on it?
The library logo.
East Baltimore Public Library, across the chest. And what was I carrying?
Books.
Textbooks. And clipped to my belt?
An employee badge.
My library employee identification badge, with my photograph on it. Officer Williams, in your twenty-two years on the force— the officer's eyes flicked up; he had not said twenty-two years, Hale had, in direct, and Marcus had kept it the way he kept everything, filed and ready "—how many armed robbers, in your experience, commit a robbery and then walk home in a bright yellow shirt with their name and photograph clipped to their belt, carrying textbooks?"
Objection, Hale said, more out of reflex than hope. "Argumentative."
Sustained, Morrison said. "Move on, Mr. Williams."
Yes, Your Honor. He turned a page, and the room had begun to understand his rhythm by now: he was not building toward a shout. There would be no shout. There was only the accumulation, question laid against question like courses of brick, and the officer's answers getting shorter as the questions got longer, and everyone in the room able to feel the wall going up. "Officer, the robbery occurred at approximately eight-forty. You stopped me at nine. Twenty minutes. In those twenty minutes, did you find a weapon on me?"
No.
Money?
No.
A baseball cap?
No.
Did officers search the route between the store and the place you stopped me — the route a fleeing man would have taken?
Units canvassed.
And did that canvass recover a weapon, money, a cap, or any item connected to the robbery?
Not that I'm aware of.
Now the show-up. After you handcuffed me, I was held on that sidewalk, between two officers, under a spotlight, for how long before Mr. Davis was driven past?
Not long. Some minutes.
Approximately fifteen minutes, according to the radio log. During those fifteen minutes, was I free to leave?
You were detained.
Detained. Hands cuffed behind my back. Two officers, one on either side of me. A spotlight on my face so bright I couldn't see the street. Is that a fair description?
That's standard for a felony stop.
Standard, Marcus said. "Officer, during those fifteen minutes, did anyone tell me why I was being held?"
You were told you matched a description.
A description, Marcus said. "Six feet. Dark clothing. A cap." He paused, and this time the pause was not a weapon but a courtesy, giving the man room to hear himself. "Officer Williams, I want to be precise about something, because I think it matters to this Court. You were doing your job that night. A man had been robbed. You went toward it, not away from it. I'm not asking this Court to think badly of you for stopping someone three blocks from a robbery. I'm asking the Court to look at what happened next — at the difference between stopping a man and staging him. The handcuffs were for safety. The fifteen minutes were for transport that never came. But the spotlight, Officer. Whose idea was the spotlight?"
It was on the unit. It was already on.
It was already on, Marcus said gently. "And nobody turned it off. And nobody thought — in fifteen minutes — that the man in the light might be a library employee walking home from work, and that the witness being driven toward him deserved a fairer question than the one he got."
He let that rest a moment before he went on.
Was I shown to Mr. Davis as part of a group?
No.
Was he shown photographs of other men?
No.
He was shown one man. In handcuffs. In a spotlight. And the officer driving him — that was Officer Brennan — said what, as the car slowed?
The officer shifted for the first time. "I wasn't in the car."
You were standing beside me. You heard it.
Another pause, longer. "He said, 'We got him — is this the man?'"
'We got him.' Marcus let the words stand in the room all by themselves, the way his grandfather — a man he had never met, dead before he was born, whose voice existed only in his mother's imitations of it — used to say a thing once and let the echo do the rest. "Officer Williams, before that night, had you ever seen me before?"
No.
Did you know I worked at the library three blocks from where you stopped me? That I had left my shift at nine o'clock, as I did every night, and was walking the same route home I had walked for over a year?
No.
No further questions, Your Honor.
He sat down. The officer remained in the witness chair for a moment after Morrison excused him, as if the geography of the room had changed and he needed a second to learn it again. In the press row, nobody was writing. They were all watching Morrison. And Morrison was watching the middle distance above the courtroom door with an expression that Lauren Mitchell, who had spent eleven years in Baltimore courtrooms and had seen this judge reduce grown attorneys to stammering boys, had never seen on him before: he looked like a man sitting in a theater, watching a play he had attended once before, from the stage this time instead of the wings — watching himself, four months younger, laughing from that very bench, reaching for his gavel, saying the word boy like it was a verdict. The reporters were watching him watch it. He knew they were watching him watch it. He straightened the file in front of him with great care, and when he spoke, he spoke to the clerk, and his voice was a door closing very quietly.