Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Mr. Williams. The judge's voice dropped into the register that courtrooms are built to amplify. "You are not a lawyer. You are a defendant. There is a difference, and the difference is standing exactly where you're standing, in those." His eyes moved, pointedly, to the handcuffs. "Your counsel will speak for you. That's what she's for." He glanced toward the defense table with the air of a man consulting a prop. "Ms. Mitchell. Does your client have anything that needs saying, or shall we proceed to the part where the State tells me why he shouldn't see daylight?"

Lauren Mitchell stood up too fast and nearly took her file with her. She was twenty-nine years old, eleven months out of law school, carrying ninety open felonies in a bag that had belonged to her predecessor, and she had met her client for the first time that morning through a door with a slot in it. She smoothed the front of her blouse with one hand.

Your Honor, my client is eighteen, no priors, lifelong resident, he's employed, he has a — a college acceptance, Your Honor, a full scholarship, and we would ask the court to consider release on recognizance with—

We would ask, Morrison repeated, tasting it. "The State?"

Hale rose the way water rises — without hurry, because it knows where it's going. "Your Honor, the State's position is that this defendant held a gun on a sixty-four-year-old store clerk for the contents of a cash register. The State requests he be held without bail."

Gun, the judge said. "Was a gun recovered, Mr. Hale?"

Not as yet, Your Honor. The investigation is ongoing.

Not as yet. Morrison nodded slowly, and now he was enjoying himself in the deeper way, the way of a man who has found the shape of an afternoon. He looked back at Marcus. "Well. Mr. Williams. It seems you have misplaced the State's gun. Careless of you. Anything else you'd like to misplace? Your freedom, perhaps — oh. It appears you already have."

This time some of the gallery did laugh — two people, three, a short ugly burst that died quickly in the heat. Marcus felt it go through him the way weather goes through a house with the windows open. He kept his eyes on the judge. In his head, in the voice he had been training since he was fourteen in the back of a library, the law spoke its clean sentences. Presumption of innocence. Burden of proof. The State shall. The court must. They rose in him now not as comfort but as architecture: the shape of a room that was supposed to exist inside this room, and didn't.

Your Honor, he said.

It was the third time. The bailiff shifted his weight. Doherty had seen defendants shout, and weep, and once, memorably, sing. He had never seen one simply persist, quietly, in the grammar of the place, and something in it made the back of his neck prickle.

Morrison's hand moved toward the gavel. It hovered there, above the sounding block, in the half-second of silence a courtroom produces before a thing becomes official and therefore true.

One thing, Your Honor, Marcus said, into that half-second, and the steadiness of it — the plain, citation-ready steadiness — reached every corner of the room. "Before the court rules on bail. Maryland Rule 4-216.1 requires this court to consider the least restrictive conditions that will reasonably ensure my appearance — and the Court of Appeals held in Fontaine v. State that a defendant's age, his ties to the community, and a pending full scholarship are factors the court is obligated to weigh on the record. Not permitted, Your Honor. Obligated. I'm asking the court to weigh them on the record. That's all I'm asking. Sir."

The gavel did not fall.

At the stenographer's machine, Mrs. Okafor — thirty-one years a court reporter, a woman who had typed murders and divorces into the record without her face changing — looked up.

She looked up over her machine at the boy in the oversized suit, and her fingers, for the first time in thirty-one years that anyone in that room could remember, stopped moving, because for one clean second she had forgotten that her job was to write it all down and not, under any circumstances, to listen.

Four months earlier, the air in the Benjamin Banneker High School auditorium had been the same temperature and an entirely different substance, because it had been full of hope, which changes the chemistry of a room the way incense changes a church.

Three hundred people filled the folding chairs and the bleachers. It was June, and Baltimore was already sweating through its shirt, and the auditorium's air conditioning had been broken since the second Bush administration, so the programs the school had printed — thick paper, gold seal, the names of one hundred and ninety-two graduates — were being used as fans, a hundred and ninety-two futures fluttering in a hundred hands. Somebody's grandmother had brought a tambourine. Nobody had asked her not to.

Marcus stood behind the curtain at stage left with the speech in his breast pocket and the other copy in his hand, because he had learned long ago that paper failed and memory didn't, and he wanted both.

He was not nervous. That was the strange thing he would remember later, standing in the holding cell with his forehead against the painted cinder block: he had not been nervous. He had been something better than calm. He had been certain — not of himself, exactly, but of the sentence he was carrying, the way a man carrying a full glass across a crowded room is certain not of his balance but of the water.

And now, said Dr. Amara Osei, the principal, into a microphone that fed back once, sweetly, "our valedictorian. Marcus Aurelius Williams."

His full name. His mother had named him for an emperor who wrote meditations in a tent on the edge of a war, and she had done it on purpose, and for eighteen years the full name had been a kind of private weather between them — Marcus Aurelius, said at the kitchen table, said over report cards, said once, memorably, over a broken curfew and a sprained ankle. Hearing it in the auditorium, in Dr. Osei's careful voice, he felt it settle on his shoulders like the gown itself.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part