Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The neighborhood knew. East Baltimore had always known; the neighborhood had known before the newspapers, because the neighborhood kept its own records, in beauty shops and on stoops and across the counters of stores that operated behind bulletproof glass. What Marcus had not expected was the *gentleness*. It arrived from every direction and it had a weight to it, like being carried. Old men who had nodded at him for eighteen years now stopped him to shake his hand with both of theirs. Miss Earlene Boyd's second cousin, who lived two streets over, sent a pound cake through a neighbor with no note and no name, and everyone understood it was an apology traveling the only route apologies could travel. The kids in his reading program asked where his college was and he said, "Next year," and they accepted it the way children accept weather, and somehow that was the hardest kindness of all, because it had no suspicion in it.

He studied at night. Not the law of his case — that, he had by heart; he could have recited the suppression hearing transcript in his sleep, and some nights did, surfacing at 3 a.m. with Judge Morrison's voice in his ears. He studied *beyond* his case: appellate opinions, the architecture of appeals, the long grammar of how errors get named and weighed and sometimes, sometimes, undone. He read the Maryland cases on eyewitness identification with a pencil hovering and never touching — the copies were not his — and kept his notes in the notebook, in columns, in the hand that did not shake.

And in the notebook, after the columns, the opening statement grew.

He wrote it the way his grandfather had once told him sermons were written: not to be memorized, but to be *ready*. If the State made him — if Hale stood up in that courtroom and pointed at him and said the word *robber* to twelve citizens — then Marcus Williams would stand up in the suit his mother had altered and he would say what he had been composing, night by night, like a man building a boat he hoped never to launch.

*Members of the jury. My name is Marcus Williams. It is the only thing in this case that has never been in dispute, and the State has spent a year trying to take it from me and give it to another man. Let me tell you what the evidence will show, and let me start with the simplest fact in this building: at 8:40 on the night of August the fourteenth, I was at work, in a yellow shirt, under a time clock, three blocks away — and the man who was in that store had a spade tattooed on his arm and walked with a limp, and his name is not mine.*

He read it over. He crossed out *a year* and wrote *eleven months*. Accuracy, he had learned, was a form of respect — for the jury, for the record, for himself. Then he closed the notebook and turned out the light and lay in the dark listening to the sirens go past on their way to other people's emergencies, and thought: *the State is postponing because it is afraid of its own courtroom. I am not postponing anything. I am becoming.*

The message came through Lauren Mitchell, and she delivered it the way she delivered everything, without advocacy, sitting across from Marcus in the small conference room at Legal Aid with her hands folded on a legal pad she did not write on.

The State is prepared to enter a nolle pros on all counts, she said. "The morning of trial. They'll stand up, say the words, and it's over. Your record — the arrest, the charges — becomes eligible for expungement, and Hale's office will not oppose the petition. In due course, as he puts it, the whole thing comes off the books. No press release. No statement. It's structured to be quiet."

Marcus looked at the table. The conference room had the particular silence of rooms where people are told the size of their lives.

In due course, he said.

Months, realistically. Maybe the better part of a year for the full expungement to process.

And on the morning of trial, what does the record say? When he stands up. The words.

Mitchell's folded hands tightened; she was a woman who respected precision and he had learned to watch for her tells. "The standard formula. *The State enters a nolle prosequi.* The court grants it. The clerk makes the entry. That's what the record says."

What does the record say about why?

It doesn't, she said. "That's the structure of the offer, Marcus. It says nothing at all. That's what they're selling and that's what they're buying. The nothing is the product, on both sides of the table."

Outside the window, Fayette Street went about its business. Marcus thought about the word *nolle* — Latin, the language of the law he had been reading since he was fourteen: *we do not wish to prosecute*. Not *we were wrong*. Not *this young man is innocent and we took eleven months of his life on a curbside identification a judge later threw out of his own courtroom*. *We do not wish.* As if it were a matter of appetite.

Why through you? he said. "Why not in writing?"

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part