Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

Chapter 26

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Is it over? Marcus said.

No, Mitchell said. "It's *changed*. Over is a door the State has to walk through, and right now the State is standing in the hallway admiring the paint. Your trial date stands. We prepare as if we're trying this case in three weeks, because until a judge says otherwise, we are."

They arrested the man with the tattoo, Lauren.

They arrested a man with a tattoo, she said, "and if I've learned anything in fourteen years it's that the State can hold two ideas at once when one of them is embarrassment. You keep your head down. You let me watch Hale. And Marcus—" A pause, in which he could hear her choosing. "Your mother is going to want to celebrate tonight. Let her. Just don't you believe it yet. Belief is a luxury we buy after the ink dries."

That night Patricia Williams fried chicken and made the macaroni with the crust on top, and she set three places out of habit and then, looking at the third chair — his father's chair, empty eleven years — she left it set, and said grace over the food with her son's hand in hers, and thanked God for movement, for paper, for a detective with glasses on a cord, in that order. Marcus ate and let her have the evening whole. But later, washing dishes, he looked at his own hands in the dishwater and thought about Terrence Boyd's aunt on a porch in the rain, saying *you all sure this time*, and understood, with a clarity that felt like cold air, that the machine had not apologized to him. It had simply found another boy to be sure about. The difference mattered. He was not yet sure it was enough.

The first postponement arrived as a single sheet of paper, and it used the word *continuance* the way rich people use the word *later* — as a door closing politely.

The State's ballistics examination, the court was informed, required additional time. The revolver recovered from Terrence Boyd's aunt's house had to be test-fired and compared against the slug from Jimmy Davis's wall, and the laboratory's backlog was measured in months, and the State regretted, and the State requested, and Judge Morrison — who had laughed at Marcus Williams in open court and then, weeks later, suppressed the State's identification with the air of a man correcting someone else's error — granted four weeks without looking up from the paper for longer than it took to sign it.

Four weeks. Then, in the fifth week, a second sheet: a State's witness, the responding officer, was scheduled for training in another county; the State requested three more. Mitchell objected in writing, in language so controlled it burned. The objection was noted. The continuance was granted.

Marcus's trial, which had been five weeks away when he stood in a laundromat and measured a stranger's height against a doorframe, receded in front of him like a shoreline at low tide — always visible, never reached.

Harvard's fall term began on a Wednesday in late August's mirror image, in the bright beginning of September, without him.

He had known it would. The university had been kind in the way institutions are kind when kindness costs them nothing: letters from the admissions office full of words like *unusual circumstances* and *we will hold*, a financial aid officer who called personally, a dean who wrote that the offer of admission and the scholarship would wait one year, that deferral was a door held open and not a door closed. All of it was true and none of it changed the arithmetic. His classmates from Benjamin Banneker were posting photographs of dormitories. His roommate — a boy from Ohio whose name Marcus knew from a letter — had written him a friendly email asking what posters he was bringing. Marcus answered it at the library after closing, and kept the answer short and warm and did not mention courtrooms.

The deferral letter was his to write. The university required it in his own words.

He wrote it at the kitchen table on a Sunday, in one sitting, with his mother at the other end pretending to study for her certification exam and actually watching his hand move. He wrote that he was requesting deferral of his admission for one academic year due to a pending legal matter in which he was the defendant; that he maintained his innocence; that he intended to resolve the matter and matriculate the following fall; that he thanked the university for its confidence, which he intended to justify. His hand did not shake. He had decided, sometime in the weeks of paper, that shaking was a thing he would do in private or not at all, and mostly he had managed not at all.

He read it aloud to Patricia once, because she asked, and only once.

When he finished, she sat for a moment with her own book open and unlooked-at. "Your father wrote letters like that," she said. "To the union. To the landlord, that winter the heat went. A man who writes a letter like that is not asking anybody for mercy. He's informing them of the schedule." She reached across and put her hand over his, where it rested on the letter. "Mail it tomorrow, baby. Then we don't talk about Harvard like it's a funeral. It's a train that's been delayed. Trains come."

The library kept his job. Mrs. Abernathy, the branch manager — a woman who had run that building for twenty-two years and had opinions about everything in it including the ghosts — called him into her office the week the first continuance came down and told him, in the tone of a woman announcing a budget cut, that his position was his position, that his hours were his hours, and that if anyone from downtown had a question about the library employing a young man awaiting trial, they could direct it to her and enjoy the conversation. She also moved his evening duties, without comment, so that he shelved in the law section last, after closing, in the quiet — the closest thing to a sacrament her building could offer.

News in the same category

Judge Laughs at Black Teen — Courtroom Freezes When He Starts Speaking Like a Top Attorney

45 Part