Not guilty.
On the count of conspiracy to commit robbery?
Not guilty.
On the count of possession of a firearm in the commission of a felony?
Not guilty, said the machinist, "on all counts, Your Honor. Not guilty."
The sound the gallery made was not a cheer, exactly, though it had a cheer's blood in it. It was the sound a room makes when a weight it has been holding collectively, without agreeing to, is set down all at once — a long exhalation with voices in it, and Patricia Williams's cry was in the middle of it, not loud, not performed, the sound of a woman who has been brave on a schedule for four months finally being permitted, by twelve strangers, to stop. Her hands, which had held the acceptance letter so tightly and so long that its folds had worn soft as linen, opened. Simply opened, in her lap, around the letter, and lay still at last, palms up, empty and full at the same time, while her son stood at the defense table with his pencil still behind his ear and looked at her over the rail and did the thing he had not allowed himself to do in that courtroom since August.
He smiled. It was not a large smile. It was the largest thing in the room.
Morrison let the sound run its course. He did not gavel it down. He waited until the courtroom had quieted itself, the way a man waits for a church to settle after the last hymn, and he discharged the jury with the thanks of the court, and the twelve of them filed out past the defense table, and the bus driver, passing, reached out without breaking stride and touched Marcus once on the sleeve, the way you touch a shoulder at a funeral or a wedding, and was gone.
Then the judge did the thing that no one in the room — not Hale, not Lauren Mitchell, not the court reporter with her fingers resting on the keys — had expected, though perhaps, in the months since August, they should have.
He did not adjourn.
Before this court adjourns, Judge Morrison said, and his voice was not the voice he used for weather reports and sentences; it was older than that voice, and smaller, and it carried, horribly and wonderfully, to the last row of the emptying gallery, "there is a matter the court will address on its own motion, and on the record. Mr. Williams."
Marcus stood. The room, half risen to leave, sat down again as one body, as if pulled by a single wire.
Mr. Williams, the judge said. "This court — I — laughed at you in this room."
The words hung in the courtroom air where the verdict had left them, unfinished, and for a moment nobody in the room seemed willing to breathe too loudly and break them.
Mr. Williams. This court — I — laughed at you in this room.
Judge Morrison stopped. He looked down at his hands, folded on the bench in front of him, and Marcus, standing at the defense table with the verdict still ringing in his ears like a bell that had not finished sounding, understood that he was watching a man do the hardest thing a powerful man can do in public: continue.
I laughed at you, Morrison said, "while you stood there in handcuffs, in a suit that was not your own, before a single witness had been sworn or a single fact had been proved. I called you a name that no person should hear in a courtroom and no judge should ever speak from this bench. I told you that you were going to prison, and that the only question was for how long. I said it before the evidence. I said it, God help me, instead of the evidence."
The gallery was utterly still. Somewhere in the third row a woman had stopped mid-sob and forgotten to finish it. The court reporter’s fingers moved over her machine without sound, the way rain moves over a roof, and Marcus realized that everything Morrison said now was going into the same record that held the laughter. That was the point. The judge knew it, and the judge did not flinch from it.
I presumed the ending of your story because I thought I recognized the beginning of it, Morrison said. "That is the opposite of what this robe requires. The robe requires that a judge know nothing until he has been shown everything. I failed that requirement in front of a full courtroom, and I failed it at the expense of an eighteen-year-old boy whose only offense, when I first saw him, was being brought into my courtroom in chains."
He lifted his eyes then, and looked at Marcus directly, not down at him — level, the way a man looks at another man across a table.
The record of this court will reflect the following. The jury has found the defendant, Marcus Williams, not guilty on all counts. This court further orders that the verdict, and the reasons for it as they appear in the evidence — the evidence — be spread in full upon the record of this case, so that any person who reads this file, at any time, in any year to come, will read the whole of it and not a fraction.
He turned to the clerk. "Madame Clerk. You will prepare a certified copy of the complete transcript of these proceedings — arraignment through verdict — and you will furnish it to Mr. Williams at no cost to him or to his family. The cost will be borne by this court." He paused, and something moved in his face that was almost, almost a smile, though it had too much sorrow in it to be one. "For whatever wall he chooses to hang it on."