By noon I had the whole forty-seven pages spread across the table and the kitchen counter, and I had a notebook open beside them, and I was writing down what I found in the plainest language I could manage. Parcel 14-B, about 0.37 acres, utility and drainage easement, recorded in 1962. Unused for about forty years, as far as I could tell from the records, because there was no pipe and no drain and no sign that any utility company had been on that ground in decades. The HOA did not own it the way Karen claimed it owned it. The easement was a right to use the land for a purpose, not a deed to the land itself, and the purpose had been dormant for longer than I had lived in Willow Creek. I wrote that down and I underlined it twice, and then I sat back and I looked at the stumps through the kitchen window, and I felt something shift in my chest, the way a door shifts when you finally find the right key.
I called Sarah Mitchell that afternoon. I had her number from years ago, from when Emily and I had our wills drawn up, and I had kept the card in the box with the deed, tucked into the front pocket of the folder. Sarah answered on the second ring, and her voice was calm and direct, the way I remembered it, and I told her who I was and what had happened, and I did not try to make it sound smaller than it was. I told her about the nine trees, and the letter, and the fine, and the saws at six forty-seven on a Tuesday morning, and the police calling it a civil dispute. She listened without interrupting, and when I finished she asked me to bring the box and the notebook and the letter to her office the next morning, and she said she would clear an hour for me, and she said not to talk to Karen or anyone from the board until we had met. I said I would not. I had no intention of talking to Karen. I had said everything I was going to say to Karen for the moment, and it had not been enough, and now I was going to say it to someone else.
That evening Thomas came over. He knocked once and let himself in the way he always did, and he stood in the kitchen looking at the papers spread across the table, and he did not say anything for a long time. Thomas had helped Emily plant those trees. He had been there the spring we put the first apple tree in the ground, his hands in the dirt beside hers, showing her how deep to dig and how to pack the soil so the roots would take. He had worked for the city for years, and he knew how to read a map and a land record the way other men knew how to read a newspaper, and when he finally spoke his voice was low. He said he was sorry. He said he had seen the trucks that morning and he had not been able to stop them. I told him it was not his fault. I told him no one could have stopped them once they had started, not with the saws already running. He nodded, and he pulled out a chair, and he sat down, and he looked at the plat map with the drainage easement marked on it, and he put his finger on Parcel 14-B, and he said he remembered when that easement was still on the city maps as an active line, and then one year it was not, and no one had ever explained why.
We sat there until the light went out of the kitchen window, and we talked about Emily, and we talked about the trees, and we talked about the way the neighborhood had changed in the six years I had lived there. Thomas told me he had seen Karen at the mailbox the day before the letter arrived, and she had been in a hurry, and she had not stopped to talk the way she usually did. He told me she had been spending a lot of time with the developer who had been buying up lots on the far side of the subdivision, a man named Victor Hale, and that the two of them had been seen walking the back of the properties together, looking at the ground the way men look at ground when they are thinking about what to build on it. I did not know what to make of that at the time. I filed it away in my mind next to the easement and the letter and the fine, and I told myself I would come back to it when I had more to go on.