The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 13

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The survey office was a small brick building on the edge of town, with a counter in the front and rows of flat file drawers in the back, and the smell of old paper and coffee, and a woman at the desk who knew Thomas by name and waved us through without asking for anything. Robert was already there, standing at a wide table with a set of maps spread out on it, and he shook my hand, and he shook Thomas's hand, and he did not waste time on small talk. He laid my plat map beside the county's master map, and he put his finger on Parcel 14-B, and he said the same thing Sarah had said, only in the language of a man who measures land for a living. The easement was recorded in 1962. It had been for utility and drainage. It had not been used in about forty years. And the HOA's claim to the land, the claim Karen had made in her letter, did not match what the maps showed. The maps showed a burden on the land, not ownership of it, and a burden that old, for a purpose that had never been carried out, was not a blank check to cut down a man's orchard.

Robert pulled out another map, an older one, from the year the subdivision was first laid out, and he showed me where the original lot lines had been drawn, and how the easement strip ran along the back of the lots, and how my orchard had sat squarely inside the strip and also squarely inside the ground I had tended for six years. He said the law around old easements was complicated, and he was not a lawyer, and I should listen to Sarah about the legal part, but as a surveyor he could tell me this: the ground had not moved, the lines on the old maps had not moved, and if anyone was going to say the boundary was somewhere else, they would have to explain why the old maps and the new maps did not agree. I asked him if they did not agree, and he said that was the question, and that the only way to answer it was to go out to the land and look at the markers.

So we went out to the land. Thomas drove, and Robert rode in the front with his equipment in the back, and I sat in the back seat with the plat maps folded in my lap, and I watched Willow Creek go past the window, the houses I had lived beside for six years, the streets I had driven a hundred times, and I tried to see them the way Robert saw them, as lines on a map that had to match the ground under your feet. When we got to my house we walked around to the back yard, and the stumps were still there, nine of them, pale and raw in the afternoon light, and I felt the same anger I had felt that Tuesday morning, only quieter now, steadier, the kind of anger that helps you think instead of the kind that stops you from thinking.

Robert walked the back line first, slowly, with a measuring rod in his hand and his eyes on the ground, and Thomas walked beside him, pointing out where the old fence had been and where the trees had stood, and I followed behind them with the map, calling out the distances as Robert asked for them. We found the first marker near the corner of the lot, a short iron rod driven into the ground, and Robert knelt down beside it and brushed the dirt away from it with his hand, and he looked at it for a long time, and he said it was not in the right place. He said the rod had been moved, or the ground around it had been disturbed, and that the marker was sitting several feet closer to my house than the map said it should be. He said a marker that has been moved is worse than a marker that is missing, because a missing marker tells you that you do not know, and a moved marker tells you something that is not true, and if you believe it, you will draw the line in the wrong place.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part