The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 29

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Karen said, "Thomas, that is not what happened," and Thomas said, "It is what happened, Karen. You asked me, and I said yes, and I should not have." Karen said, "You are misunderstanding me," and Thomas said, "I am not misunderstanding you. I am remembering you." And then other people began to talk, not all at once, but in ones and twos, and the sound of the room changed, from quiet attention to something else, something restless, and I could feel the mood of the room turning, the way a tide turns, slowly at first, and then all at once, and Karen could feel it too, because she began to talk faster, and to say that the board had acted in good faith, and that the association had relied on advice, and that mistakes had been made, and that she had always had the best interests of the community at heart, and the more she talked, the less the room seemed to believe her.

Mark Sullivan spoke then, and he spoke carefully, the way a man speaks when he is choosing his words in front of a room full of his neighbours. He said the board had a responsibility to act on the facts, and that the facts had changed, and that the utility authority's letter was a fact, and that the survey was a fact, and that the board could not continue to interfere with my property on the basis of a claim the utility authority had now rejected. He said he was not there to blame anyone, but that the board had to decide what it was going to do, and that it had to decide it that evening, in front of the residents, and not later, in a smaller room.

Richard Lawson spoke after him, briefly, and he said that the board should take legal advice before it voted on anything, and that the injunction filing was a serious matter, and that the board should consider its position carefully, and Karen seized on that, and said, "Yes, we should take advice, we should not rush, we should table this," and for a moment it looked as if the meeting might dissolve into delay, the way so many meetings had dissolved into delay before, and I felt my hands tighten on the edge of the table, and Sarah put her hand, very lightly, on my arm, and she did not say anything, and I understood what she meant, which was to wait, and to let the room do what the room was going to do.

The room did it. A woman I did not know well, from two streets over, stood up and said, "We have waited long enough. We are here. Vote." And another man said, "Vote," and another, and the sound of it went around the room, and Mark Sullivan looked at Karen, and Karen looked at the table, and Mark Sullivan said, "I move that the board vote this evening on ending the association's interference with Mr. Daniel's property on Parcel 14-B, and on recognising that the association holds no easement and no right of access over that parcel."

There was a second, and then there was a vote, and it was not close, and it was not quiet. Four board members voted in favour. One voted against. The vote was four to one, to end the interference with my property.

I remember the moment the vote landed the way I remember the morning I found the orchard gone, only in reverse. The morning the orchard was gone, the world had gone quiet and flat, and everything had seemed very far away. The moment the vote landed, the world came back, all at once, and the room filled with sound, people talking, and chairs moving, and someone clapping, and someone else saying my name, and Thomas turning around in his chair to look at me, and Sarah leaning back in her chair and letting out a breath I had not realised she had been holding, and Karen sitting very still at the centre of the table, with her hands folded in front of her, and her face closed, and Richard Lawson closing his folder, slowly, and putting his pen down.

I did not stand up. I did not say anything. I sat there, with my hands still flat on the table, and I felt the relief come over me in a wave, and then another wave behind it, and I thought about Emily, and I thought about the nine trees, and I thought about the letter, and I thought about the map, and I thought about the markers in the ground, and I thought about how long it had taken, and how much it had cost, and how much it had not undone, and I thought about the fact that the board had voted, in front of dozens of my neighbours, to stop, and that the stopping was real, and that it was on the record, and that it could not be taken back by a quiet conversation in a smaller room.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part