The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 4

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I dialed 911 with hands that were shaking so hard I had to steady the phone against my thigh. I told the dispatcher what was happening. Men in my yard. A crew cutting down my trees. I gave her my address, my name, the name of the company, the name of the woman who had sent them. She told me to stay calm, to stay inside if I felt unsafe, that an officer would be dispatched. I told her I was not going inside. I was not leaving my yard while there were still trees standing in it.

The crew did not cut anything while I was on the phone. The manager stood by the truck, talking quietly on his own phone, and I heard him say the name Whitfield twice, and then he said, "Yes, ma'am," and then he said, "He's out here now," and then he put the phone away and looked at me, and I knew, without him telling me, that Karen Whitfield had told him to keep going, or to wait, or to do whatever she had decided was going to happen that morning, and that my standing in the yard in my bare feet was not going to change her mind.

The police came, eventually. Two officers, a man and a woman, in a patrol car that pulled up behind the TreePro truck. They walked into the yard the way police walk into a yard, slowly, taking everything in, their hands resting near their belts, their eyes moving from the fallen tree to the stump to the crew to me. I showed them the photographs on my phone. I showed them the video. I told them about the letter, about the hearing I had asked for, about the reply I had sent. The female officer listened, and nodded, and wrote things down in a small notebook. The male officer talked to the manager, and then he came back to me, and he said the words I had been afraid he would say.

"Sir, this looks like a civil dispute. The HOA says they have the authority. You say they don't. That's something a court has to decide, not us. We can't stop a work crew on private property when there's a dispute over who has the right to be there. I know that's not what you want to hear. But that's where we are."

"A civil dispute," I said. "They're cutting down my wife's trees. They're cutting them down right now, while we stand here talking."

"I understand," he said. "And I'm sorry. But if I stop them and the HOA turns out to have the right, then I've interfered with a lawful job. If I let them go and you turn out to have the right, then you've got a claim for damages. Either way, this is going to be decided with paperwork, not with a patrol car."

He gave me a card with a case number on it. I wrote the number down in the small notebook I keep in my pocket, the one I have carried since Emily died, the one where I write down the dates I prune the trees and the dates the blossoms open and the dates the first fruit ripens, and now, the date a crew came into my yard and cut my orchard down, and the name of the officer, and the time, 7:31 a.m., and the words "civil dispute," underlined twice, because I wanted to remember exactly what they had said and exactly how little it had helped.

It was only then, with the officers' car pulling away and the crew standing around the truck, that I remembered the phone call. Thomas. My phone had been ringing when the chainsaw started, or just before, and I had let it go because I was still half asleep, and now I pulled the phone out of my pocket and saw his name on the screen, and the voicemail waiting, and I pressed play and held the phone to my ear, and there was his voice, rough and hurried, the voice of a man who had seen something happening and run for the phone.

"Daniel, it's Thomas. They're in your yard. The TreePro truck, they're cutting the trees. I saw them pull up, I saw the saws. Get out there, Daniel. Get out there now."

I called him back. He answered on the first ring. "Daniel? Did you stop them? Tell me you stopped them."

"They cut one down," I said. "An apple. And half a cherry. The police came. They said it's civil. They said paperwork."

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part