The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 32

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The mood of the board, in those days, was something I watched from a distance, the way you watch weather moving across a field. Thomas told me what he heard, because Thomas knew people, and people talked to Thomas, and Linda told me what she heard at the grocery store and at the school pickup line, and Sarah Mitchell told me what she heard through the formal channels, which was less but more precise. The board was, in Thomas's word, shaken. Not angry, not yet. Shaken, the way a house is shaken after a small earthquake, when everything is still standing but nothing is quite where it was, and every door sticks a little when you try to open it. The members who had voted with Karen, who had signed their names to the approval, were walking around the neighborhood with their heads down, and when they saw me they either nodded too quickly or looked away too fast, and I understood that. I understood it because I had done the same thing myself, years ago, when I had let someone else make a decision for me and then had to live with the shape of it. It is a particular kind of shame, the shame of having been careless with someone else's life, and it does not wash off quickly.

Mark called me on the fifth day after the vote. He did not write this time. He called, and his voice on the phone sounded tired, the way a man's voice sounds when he has not been sleeping well, and he asked if he could come by, just for ten minutes, and I said yes, because I wanted to see his face when he said the things he had written. He came that evening, just after six, and he stood on my porch for a moment before he knocked, the way people do when they are gathering themselves, and when I opened the door he was holding his hat in his hands, turning it around and around, and he would not look at the yard, would not look at the stumps, and I knew he could not look at them yet, and I did not make him. We sat at the kitchen table, and he said the same things he had written, only slower, and with more pauses, and I listened, and when he was finished I told him that I appreciated the letter, and that I appreciated him coming, and that I was not ready to say that everything was all right, because it was not all right, and he nodded, and he said he understood, and he said that was fair, and then he asked what he could do, not in general, but specifically, and I told him the truth, which was that I did not know yet, and that I would tell him when I did.

But an apology does not undo a chainsaw. I want to be clear about that, because it is the thing I kept coming back to in those days, the thing I turned over in my mind every morning when I looked out the kitchen window and saw the stumps instead of the trees. The stumps were still there, nine of them, cut low and clean, the wood pale and raw where the saw had gone through, and every time I looked at them I could see, in my mind, the way the trees had stood, the way the apple branches had spread in the spring, the way the cherry blossoms had come out in a white rush that made the whole yard smell sweet, the way the peach trees had leaned a little toward the sun in the late afternoon. An apology letter, however sincere, does not make a stump into a tree again. It does not put back the years it took for those trees to grow. Emily planted the first apple tree the spring after we moved in, and I planted the last peach tree the year before she got sick, and those trees were not landscaping. They were a calendar. They were the years of our life together, measured in blossom and fruit, and you cannot apologize a calendar back into existence.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part