The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 6

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Thomas put his hand on my shoulder. "You keep the photos," he said. "You keep everything. Every paper, every date. That's how you beat people like her. Not by shouting. By having the proof when she doesn't."

"I know," I said. "I'm going to."

The officers left. The crew did not leave. They stood around the truck for a while, drinking water from plastic bottles, waiting, I suppose, for someone to tell them what to do next. The manager was on his phone again. The young worker came over to me, hesitant, holding his cap in his hands.

"Mister," he said, "do you want to keep the firewood? I mean, it's good wood. Applewood burns nice. My dad used to say applewood is the best for a smoker. We can stack it for you, by the fence, if you want. No charge."

I looked at him. He was young enough that he might not have lost anyone yet. He might not have known what it was to watch something that had been alive for six years, something you had tended with your own hands, turned into firewood in a morning. Or maybe he did know, and that was why he was offering, because stacking the wood was the only kind thing he could think to do in a situation where kindness had already run out.

"No," I said. "I don't want the firewood."

He nodded, and he went back to the truck, and I stood there among the trees, or what was left of them, and I thought about the letter that had started all of this, the letter that had arrived on the Friday before, four days earlier, in a plain white envelope with the Willow Creek Homeowners Association letterhead on it, and Karen Whitfield's signature at the bottom.

It had come in the afternoon mail, and I had opened it standing at the kitchen counter, the way you open a letter when you are not expecting anything important, with a knife from the drawer, one quick slit, and then the paper unfolding in my hands. The first line was my name and address, printed, impersonal. The second line was the word "Violation." The letter said that my orchard, my nine trees, violated section 7.3 of the association's rules, a rule about permanent structures, and that the trees were to be removed before 6 a.m. on Monday, or I would face a fine of four hundred and fifty dollars, plus twenty-five dollars a day for every day the violation continued.

Section 7.3. A rule about permanent structures. I read the letter twice, and then a third time, standing there in the kitchen with the afternoon light coming through the window, and I felt the same disbelief I had felt that morning in the yard, the disbelief of a man being told that a thing he knows to be true is false. Trees are not a permanent structure. A tree is a living thing. It grows. It changes. It sheds its leaves and grows them back. It is the opposite of a structure. A structure is a shed, a fence, a wall. A tree is not a shed. Anyone who has ever planted a tree knows that.

I wrote back the same evening. I sat at the kitchen table, the same table where Emily and I had eaten a thousand dinners, and I wrote a letter by hand first, because I think better with a pen in my hand, and then I typed it up, and I printed it, and I signed it, and I made a copy for myself, and I put the copy in the folder where I keep everything to do with the house, the folder with the deed and the insurance papers and the receipts for the trees, each one saved, each one dated, because Emily had taught me to keep receipts and I had never stopped.

In my reply I said, plainly, that the trees were not a permanent structure, that they had been planted with the knowledge of the association, that they had stood for six years without a single complaint, that they were maintained, pruned, and healthy, and that I was attaching photographs to prove it. I printed the photographs on the home printer, eight of them, the orchard in spring with the blossom thick on the branches, the orchard in summer with the fruit heavy and green, the orchard in autumn with the leaves turning gold, and I paper-clipped them to the letter in order, spring, summer, autumn, winter, the whole year of the trees, the whole life of them. I asked, formally, for a board hearing, in writing, as the rules said I was entitled to, and I filed a formal complaint about the way the notice had been handled, and I sent it by certified mail so there would be a record, a green card coming back to me with a signature on it, proof that someone had received it.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part