I never got a hearing. I never got an answer. What I got, four days later, was a chainsaw at 6:47 on a Tuesday morning.
Karen Whitfield. I had known her for six years, the whole time I had lived in Willow Creek, and I had never once had a conversation with her that left me feeling like we were on the same side of anything. She was the president of the homeowners association, and she ran it the way some people run a small kingdom, with rules that were always being discovered, always being enforced, always, somehow, in her favor. She lived three houses down, in the largest house on the street, with a lawn so perfect it looked painted on, and a driveway with two cars, and a mailbox with her name on it in brass letters. She had never once come to my yard. She had never once asked me about the trees. She had never once, in six years, said a kind word about Emily, or about the orchard, or about anything that mattered to me.
And now she was standing at the end of my driveway, in the morning light, in a white blouse and dark slacks, her arms folded, watching the crew, watching me, and when I walked toward her, still barefoot, still holding my phone, she did not step back. She looked at the fallen apple tree, and she looked at me, and she said, in a voice as calm and certain as a judge reading a sentence, "This land is not yours anymore."
I stared at her. The words did not make sense. Not yours anymore. I had lived here six years. I had paid the mortgage every month. I had planted the trees with my wife. I had buried my wife, and I had come home to this house, and I had kept living in it, and I had kept tending the trees, and now this woman was standing in my driveway telling me that the land was not mine anymore, as if she could say it and make it true, as if a sentence spoken in a calm voice on a Tuesday morning could undo six years of a life.
"What do you mean?" I said. "What are you talking about?"
She did not answer. She turned and walked back toward her car, and the manager came over to me and said the crew was going to pause for now, that they would be back, that I should take it up with the board, and the young worker looked at me one more time, and the truck started up, and they drove away, slowly, leaving the fallen apple tree on the grass and the half-cut cherry leaning like a wounded animal and the stump shining wet in the sun.
I stood there for a long time after they left. I do not know how long. The bird was still singing. The smell of cut wood was still in the air. I walked to the stump of the apple tree and I put my hand on it, the way Emily had put her hand on the trunk of the first tree all those years ago, and the wood was warm from the sun and wet from the sap, and I could feel the rings under my palm, six years of growth, six years of rain and sun and pruning and patience, ended in a morning. I counted the rings again, slowly, the way I had counted the trees when I first ran out into the yard, because counting was the only thing that made the morning feel real instead of like a dream I would wake from. Six rings. Six years. The tree had been alive for the whole of our life in this house, and it had been cut down in less time than it takes to drink a cup of coffee, and nobody had asked me, and nobody had waited for a hearing, and nobody had given me a chance to speak. That was the part that stayed with me, more than the sound of the saw, more than the smell of the sap. Not the cutting itself, but the fact that it had been done as if my voice did not count, as if the six years did not count, as if Emily had never stood in this yard with her hand on a trunk and said ten years.