At Sarah's office, we went through the file together, page by page, and she asked me questions, and I answered them, and she wrote notes in the margins, and she told me what she needed and what she did not need, and she told me to be honest with her about anything I was not sure of, because a court would ask the same questions, and it was better to know the answer in her office than to find out in a courtroom. I told her everything I knew, and I told her what I did not know, and she did not make me feel foolish for either. When we were done, the file was forty-seven pages thick, and she tapped the top of it with her hand and said, "This is a strong file, Daniel. It is not a loud file. It is a strong one. The map, the markers, the letter, the photographs, the video. They all point the same way."
She filed it the next day. She called me in the afternoon and told me it was filed with the county court, and that the HOA would be served, and that there would be a hearing date, and that in the meantime the injunction would ask the court to order the HOA to stop interfering with my property while the matter was decided. I thanked her, and I hung up, and I sat in my kitchen, and I waited, because waiting was what came next, and I had become good at waiting, though I had never wanted to be.
The waiting was the hardest part, harder than the morning I found the orchard gone, harder than the meetings where Karen had talked over me, harder than the nights I had lain awake and gone over every conversation I had ever had with her, looking for the moment when I should have seen it coming. Waiting meant that the file was out of my hands, and that other people were reading it, and that I could not do anything to make them read it faster, or to make them see what I saw in it. I went to work. I came home. I ate dinner standing up at the counter more often than I sat down at the table. I walked out to the stumps in the evening, and I came back in, and I checked my phone, and I checked the mail, and I waited for Sarah to call, and when she did call, it was usually to ask me one more question, or to tell me one more thing she had filed, or to tell me that there was no news yet, and that no news was not bad news.
One night, about a week after the filing, Thomas came over again, and he brought a six-pack of beer, and we sat on the back porch, and we did not talk about the case at all for the first hour, and then he said, "Do you think it will be enough?" and I said, "I think it has to be. The letter says what it says. The map says what it says. The markers are in the ground. I do not know what else there is." He nodded, and he said, "I think it will be enough too. I just wanted to hear you say it." We finished the beer, and he went home, and I stayed on the porch for a while, listening to the night sounds, and thinking about Emily, and thinking about the orchard, and thinking about how strange it was that a piece of paper from 1962 could matter so much to a man in the present, and how grateful I was that someone, sixty-odd years ago, had written it down properly, and had kept it, and had not let it be forgotten.
Sarah called me on a Thursday morning, two weeks after the filing, and told me the board had called a meeting, and that it was going to be a crowded one, and that she wanted me there, and that she wanted to present the file to the board herself, in person, in front of the residents, before the hearing. "They need to see it," she said. "Not just hear about it. See it. The map, the letter, the markers. They need to see it all together, in one room, at one time." I asked her if that was wise, and she said, "It is wise because it is true, and because the longer this stays in letters and filings, the more room there is for people to pretend it is complicated. It is not complicated. The utility holds the easement. The HOA does not. The rest follows from that."