They had bought them together, Thomas and Linda and a handful of other neighbors, and they had gone to the nursery out on the county road, the same nursery where Emily and I had bought the first apple tree all those years ago, and they had picked out nine young trees, three apple, three cherry, three peach, the same as before, not because anyone had told them to, but because they had asked me, weeks earlier, in a quiet conversation at Thomas's kitchen table, what had been there, and I had told them, and they had remembered. The total cost of the new trees was about four thousand two hundred dollars, and when Thomas told me that number, standing in my yard with dirt already on his hands, he said it the way a man says a number that does not matter, quickly, almost embarrassed, as if the money were the least important part of it, and he was right. The money was the least important part. What mattered was that they had gone, and they had chosen, and they had paid, and they had brought the trees back in the bed of Thomas's truck, wrapped in burlap, the roots damp and dark, the branches thin and bare, and they had laid them out on the grass in a row, nine small trees, and they looked so small next to the stumps that I felt my throat close up, because a young tree is a promise, and a promise is a fragile thing, and I had not been sure, until that morning, that I was ready to make another one.
But then Linda took my arm, gently, the way she had taken it a hundred times since Emily died, and she said, "We will plant them where they were, Daniel. The same places. We measured." And I looked at the yard, and I saw that they had, that they had marked the spots with little wooden stakes, nine of them, driven into the ground where the old trees had stood, and the stakes were in a pattern I recognized, because it was Emily's pattern, the pattern she had laid out with string and a tape measure on a Saturday morning twenty years ago, three apple trees along the back fence, three cherry trees in a row down the middle, three peach trees near the patio where the sun hit hardest in the afternoon. And I thought about Emily, and about the way she had stood in that yard with her hands on her hips, telling me where each tree would go, and I thought about how strange it was that a group of neighbors with a tape measure and a memory could bring her back into the yard like that, not as a ghost, but as a plan, a plan that was still good, a plan that still worked.
The work of planting took most of the day. We dug holes, and the soil was dark and rich from the rain, and it came up easily, and the smell of it, that deep, clean smell of turned earth, got into my clothes and under my nails, and I did not mind, because it was the smell of something beginning. Thomas dug the first hole, and he dug it deep, deeper than it needed to be, because that is the way Thomas does things, and Linda held the first tree steady while I shoveled the soil back in around the roots, and we tamped it down with our feet, and we watered it, and we stepped back, and there it was, a young apple tree, thin and bare and hopeful, standing where the old apple tree had stood, and I looked at it, and I thought, that is a start. That is a start. And then we did the next one, and the next one, and the work settled into a rhythm, dig, hold, fill, tamp, water, step back, and the neighbors worked in pairs, and then in threes, and the yard filled with the sound of shovels and laughter and people talking over each other. Their hands were in the soil. That is the image I carry with me from that day, more than any other. Neighbors' hands in the soil, brown with earth, pressing the ground firm around the roots of young trees, and the soil under their fingernails, and the way they wiped their hands on their jeans afterward, and the way they stood back and looked at what they had done, their faces flushed from the work, their shirts sticking to their backs. That was what making it right looked like, not a letter, not a vote, but hands in the dirt.
I was reimbursed thirty-eight thousand dollars for the trees and the related damage. Sarah Mitchell handled that, and she handled it the way she handled everything, carefully and completely, and when she told me the number, she laid it out for me, line by line, the value of the mature trees, the cost of the removal and the cleanup, the damage to the soil and the fence, the work that would have to be done to make the yard whole again. Thirty-eight thousand dollars. It was a fair number, and I knew it was a fair number, and I was grateful for it, because it meant that the community, and the HOA, and the people responsible, were not just saying they were sorry, they were paying for what had been done. But I want to be honest about what that money felt like, because it did not feel like a victory, and it did not feel like justice, not exactly. It felt like a number that had been written down on a piece of paper to stand in for something that could not be written down. You cannot put a price on twenty years of blossom. You cannot put a price on a peach tree that Emily planted with her own hands. The money would pay for the new trees, and it would pay for the work, and it would pay for the things that had been broken, and that mattered, because a man has to live, and a yard has to be repaired, but the money was not the trees, and I knew that, and Sarah knew that, and she did not pretend otherwise. She just handed me the settlement papers, and she said, "This is what they owe you, Daniel. It is not what they took. Nothing will ever be that. But it is what they owe you." And I signed, and I put the papers in the drawer with the letters and the survey and the easement, and I went outside, and I watered the young trees, one by one, slowly, the way Emily used to water them, and I thought, all right. All right. We are going to grow these.