The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 12

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I asked her if a lawsuit was what I wanted, and she looked at me for a long moment, and she said that was a question only I could answer, but that I should not answer it that day. She said I should go home and think about what the orchard had meant, and what Emily had meant, and what it would mean to let a single letter and a morning of saws be the end of it. She said some people took a small settlement and moved on, and some people did not, and neither choice was wrong, but the choice had to be mine, and it had to be made with my eyes open. I told her I would think about it. I did not tell her what I was already thinking, which was that I had spent four years keeping Emily's trees alive, and I was not going to let the woman who had them cut down buy her way out of it with a check that would not even cover the cost of the wood.

When I got home that afternoon Thomas was waiting on my porch, and he had a look on his face I had not seen before, the look of a man who has been carrying something he does not want to carry and has finally decided to set it down. He followed me into the kitchen, and he sat at the table, and he told me something I had not known, something that changed the shape of everything I had been reading in those forty-seven pages. He said Karen had promised him, months ago, that she would take care of the permit for a rear access road. He said the road was supposed to run along the back of the properties, along the strip where the easement was, and that it was supposed to give the developer's trucks a way in and out without going through the front of the neighborhood. He said Victor Hale was behind it, that Victor had been the one asking for the road, and that Karen had told Thomas not to worry, that she would handle the permit herself, that it was all but done. Thomas said he had believed her at the time, because she was the HOA president and she spoke like someone who could make things happen, but now, with the trees gone and the ground cleared, he was not so sure the road and the trees were two separate stories. He thought they might be the same story, and the trees might have been in the way of something Karen and Victor had already planned.

I sat with that for a while, and I thought about the rear access road, and I thought about the strip of land at the back of my yard, and I thought about the way the saws had come on a Tuesday morning without warning, and the pieces started to fit together in a way I did not like. A road needs cleared ground. A road needs a strip of land that no one is using, or that no one is allowed to use anymore. Nine trees take up a lot of ground, and a man who wants a road does not want to wait for a homeowner to agree to take his trees down. I did not have proof, not yet, but I had a shape, and the shape was enough to make my decision for me. I told Thomas I was not going to take a small settlement. I told him I was not going to let Karen or Victor Hale or anyone else pay me a little money and walk away as if the orchard had never been there. I was going to see it through, whatever that meant, and whatever it cost, because Emily had planted those trees with her own hands, and Thomas had helped her, and I had watered them through four summers after she was gone, and no one was going to turn that into a line item on a developer's budget.

Thomas nodded, and he said he would help me however he could, and he said the next thing I needed was not another look at the papers in my kitchen but a look at the land itself, with someone who knew how to read it. He said he knew a surveyor, a man named Robert Chen, who had done work all over Willow Creek, and who had surveyed half the lots in the subdivision when it was first built. He said Robert was honest, and careful, and that he remembered things about the ground that other people had forgotten. I called Robert that evening, and he agreed to meet us at the survey office the next morning, and he told me to bring the plat maps and the deed, and to bring Thomas too, because Thomas knew the land the way a man knows a place he has walked for years.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part