The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 27

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

I spent the days before the meeting preparing with her, and the preparation was not dramatic. It was careful. We went over the forty-seven pages again, and she asked me to explain, in my own words, what each part of it showed, and I did, and she corrected me where I was imprecise, and she told me not to argue, and not to raise my voice, and not to answer Karen directly if Karen tried to draw me into an argument, because the file was the argument, and the file did not need my help. "Let the map speak," she said. "Let the letter speak. Let the markers speak. You just sit there, and you tell the truth when you are asked, and you let the room hear it."

I also spent those days thinking about what the meeting would feel like. I had been to board meetings before, in the years since Emily died, and they had always been small affairs, a dozen people at most, in a room that smelled of coffee and old carpet, with an agenda that was mostly about fences and driveways and the colour of front doors. This one was going to be different. Sarah said dozens of residents were expected, and the room had been moved to a larger one, and the board had sent out a notice, and people were talking, and I knew, from the way Thomas talked, and from the way neighbours I barely knew stopped me on the street to ask how I was doing, that the orchard had become something people had opinions about, and that the meeting was going to be the place where those opinions came out into the open.

The night before the meeting, I could not sleep. I lay in bed and I listened to the house, and I thought about the nine trees, and I thought about Emily, and I thought about the letter, and I thought about the vote that might come, and I thought about the vote that might not come, and I thought about what I would do if the board refused to listen, and I thought about what I would do if they did listen, and I realised, somewhere in the middle of the night, that I did not know what I would do if they did listen, because I had spent so long preparing for a fight that I had not prepared for the possibility of winning one. I got up and I made tea, and I sat at the kitchen table, and I looked at the folder, and I read the letter one more time, and I went back to bed, and I slept, finally, in the small hours, and when I woke up it was morning, and the meeting was that evening, and the day stretched out in front of me like a road I had already walked once and was about to walk again.

The meeting room was already full when I arrived, and I had arrived early. There were more people there than I had ever seen at a board meeting in Willow Creek, dozens of them, filling the rows of folding chairs and standing along the back wall, and the air in the room was warm and close, and there was a low sound of people talking that stopped, in pieces, as Sarah and I came in. I saw faces I knew and faces I did not know well, and I saw Thomas near the front, and he gave me a small nod, and I nodded back, and I sat down beside Sarah at the table at the front of the room, and I put my hands flat on the table, and I waited.

Karen Whitfield sat at the centre of the board table, with Mark Sullivan, the board vice president, to her right, and the other board members arranged on either side of her, and Richard Lawson, the HOA lawyer, sat a little apart from them, with a leather folder in front of him and a pen in his hand, and he did not look at me when I sat down. Karen looked at me, and she smiled, the way she had smiled at me in other meetings, a smile that was meant to look reasonable, and she said, "Thank you all for coming. We have a full agenda this evening," and she began to talk about the order of business, and about the minutes, and about a fence, and about a driveway, as if this were an ordinary meeting, and as if the room were not full of people who had come for one reason.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part