Most of them were like that. Most of them were on my side, and they said so plainly, in their own words, and each time one of them sat down I felt something loosen in my chest, a little at a time. But not all of them were. The seventh speaker was a man I recognized from the board's mailing list, and he said that the HOA had the right to enforce its rules, that the parcel had been a problem for years, that nobody had maintained it properly, and that sometimes a board had to act even when people did not like it. He did not look at me while he said it. He looked at Karen. And the eighth speaker, a woman with her arms crossed, said that she did not trust what she was hearing, that there were always two sides, and that the board deserved the benefit of the doubt. I listened to both of them without interrupting, because Sarah had told me to, and because arguing with them in that room would not have helped me. But I felt the sting of it anyway. I felt the room split, not evenly, but split, and I understood that this was not going to be settled by applause.
When the last resident had spoken, Sarah stood up. She did not raise her voice. She never raised her voice, and that was part of what made people listen to her. She opened her folder and laid out the papers on the table in front of the board, one at a time, the way a person lays out cards. She talked about the parcel, 14-B, and about the survey Robert Chen had done, and about the original marker from 1987, the one that was still there, in the ground, where it had always been. She talked about the second marker, the one that had been moved and hidden, and about the fact that Karen had asked Robert whether the boundary could be interpreted differently, as if a boundary were a matter of opinion. She talked about the 1962 easement, and she said the word drainage slowly, so that everyone in the room could hear it, and she said that an easement for drainage was not ownership, and that it had not been used in forty years, and that not using it did not turn it into something else.
Then she asked for the minutes. She asked the board to produce the minutes of the meeting at which the cutting had been approved. She asked for the date, the vote, the names of the board members who had voted, and the written authorization for TreePro to enter the parcel. She asked it plainly, and then she waited. The room went quiet in a way I had never heard a room go quiet before, not the quiet of people who were bored, but the quiet of people who were listening for an answer.
Karen did not produce the minutes. She said that the board's records were internal, that they were not required to share them in a public meeting, that the decision had been made properly and that was all the residents needed to know. She said it calmly, the way she said everything, but I saw Mark Sullivan shift in his chair, and I saw one of the other board members look down at the table. Sarah asked again, more slowly, whether the minutes existed, and whether the board would produce them if a court asked for them, and Karen said that the board would cooperate with any proper legal process, which was not an answer to the question that had been asked. Sarah let the silence sit for a moment, and then she said that if there were no minutes, then there had been no lawful vote, and if there had been no lawful vote, then the cutting had been ordered by one person, not by a board, and that was a different matter entirely. She did not shout. She did not need to. I could feel the room change. I could feel people looking at Karen in a new way, the way you look at someone when you have just realized you do not know the whole story.
The meeting ended without a resolution. Karen adjourned it the way she always did, with a short statement and a tap of her pen against the table, and people stood up slowly, talking in low voices, gathering in small groups near the door. Several people came up to me and shook my hand, or put a hand on my shoulder, and said that they were sorry about the trees, and that they hoped I would keep going. A few others walked past me without speaking, and I did not try to stop them. Thomas stayed beside me until the room was nearly empty, and then he walked out with me into the parking lot, where the evening air was cool and the sky was going the color of bruised plums.