The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Thomas listened to all of it, and then he told her no. He told her that he had helped plant those trees, that he had watched them grow, that he had stood in Emily's kitchen and eaten peaches from them, and that he was not going to pretend he had not seen what he had seen. He told her that if the board wanted to inspect his shed, they could inspect his shed, and that he had nothing to hide. He told me about the visit that evening, sitting at his kitchen table with a cup of tea going cold between his hands, and he laughed a little when he told it, but it was not a real laugh. It was the laugh of a man who had been frightened and had decided not to be. I put my hand on his shoulder and I told him that he did not have to do this, that I would understand if he stepped back, and he looked at me and said that Emily would have done the same for him, and that was the end of the discussion.

Then another letter came from the HOA. It arrived in the mail on a Tuesday, in the same envelope they always used, with the same letterhead, and I opened it at the kitchen table, expecting another demand about the parcel. Instead, it demanded that I remove a structure from my property, a structure it described in vague terms, a shed, or a storage building, or an addition, the letter was not quite clear, and it cited a rule about unapproved structures, and it gave me thirty days to comply. The problem was that the structure did not exist. There was no shed. There was no storage building. There was no addition. There was nothing on my property that matched the description in the letter, and I walked around the yard twice, checking, because for a moment I wondered if I had misunderstood something, if there was something I had forgotten. There was not. The letter was demanding that I remove something that was not there.

I showed it to Sarah, and she read it twice, and then she set it down on her desk and said that this was what it looked like when a board had run out of real evidence. They were using generic reasons now, boilerplate language, the kind of letter that could have been sent to anyone, about anything, because they no longer had a specific case to make. She said it was a sign that they were flailing, that they knew the minutes did not exist, that they knew the survey did not support them, that they knew the county records did not support them, and so they were reaching for whatever they could find. She told me to keep the letter, and to keep the envelope, and to write down the date it arrived, because it would matter later, when someone asked what the HOA had done after the meeting, and whether they had acted in good faith. I filed it with the other papers, on top of the stack, where I could see it, and I felt a strange mixture of anger and relief. Anger, because they were still coming after me. Relief, because they were coming after me with nothing.

In the days that followed, I did what I could, and I waited. I kept the photographs organized. I kept David's video backed up in two places. I kept Thomas's statement in a folder with the county records, and I kept a notebook by the phone, writing down every call, every visit, every letter, with the date and the time. I walked the parcel in the mornings, the way I had always walked it, stepping carefully between the stumps, and I thought about Emily, and about the trees, and about how long it took for something to grow, and how fast it could be taken away. I thought about the forty-two people in the community hall, and about the signatures, and about the way Sarah had laid her papers on the table, one at a time, and asked for the minutes. I thought about Victor's offer, and about the way Karen had refused to produce what she could not produce, and about the way Thomas had stood in his kitchen and said no.

News in the same category

The HOA Cut Down My Orchard — Then They Discovered Who Owned the Land Beneath It

45 Part